He is a great footballer, it was very important for the team this season, he did nothing on ucl final to be said, but he also had a major contribution for us reaching the final , he had like 3 assists , 2 goals in 6 ko games , that's impressive , he also scored in coppa final, so he deserved a renew , but probably marotta didn't expect this happening, he was probably , I can't be sure what he ws thinking normally, but I think he was probably thinking alves will be good this season, then will likely have already an off season , meanwhile he could have done a transfer strategy , adding 2 more rbs (to get rid of lichts this summer and alves was leaving next summer) so he could add 1 new rb this year and 1 more the next summer, but the things went in an unexpected manner , I think alves' level surprised even marotta , also on this forum I don't think that anybody expected him perform in such manner in ucl ko, especially after first months when he was criticised by some juve fans , but I can't understand the likes of comments he did , you get angry , you on verge of leaving and start hit the club, it's not the attitude to encorouge, I think would have been better if he was saying this before , if he had something to say not now, also statement about dybala is truth only if you take in consideration real madrid, then yes, if we was reffering to winning , they win cl, we can't at the moment, but who knows what is gonna be in future , even if there is Juventus in final, also they have a better team also, but after real madrid I don't know if he could really improve somewhere else , juve is perfect for him, real is a difficult club to go, there is a huge pressure and I don't see Paulo's place at madrid, I might be wrong or subjective but this how I see the things, as for beppe we will find out this summer or next at latest if he had a strategy or he simply didn't want to offer new contract to alves without any back up list.