Who is the greatest Italian player ever? (14 Viewers)

[Fred]

Yes i think that this poll is pointless anyway, how many people have watched Scirea play for example? a thread about the best Italian player in the past 15-20 years would have been more appropriate.

Oh and out of curiosity Burke, do you think one can judge a player based on youtube videos??

 

Buy on AliExpress.com

[ßöмßäяðîëя]

No, but I never said anything about YouTube videos.

 

[Fred]

i know but you think its ok to judge a player you never watched, because you saw videos of his and did a little reading right?

Doesnt that mean i can judge any player that plays in any given league using wikipedia and youtube?

 

[ßöмßäяðîëя]

No, if I read about them I read credible sources.

 

[Fred]

so a credible source and youtube would be enough to judge a player i havent watched??

 

[ßöмßäяðîëя]

Not necessarily, but I'm talking about common fucking sense, jokester.

I'm saying that if I listen to your idiocy, and can't vote or judge a player I've never seen play, then I could not vote for any of the players that played before WC '98. You are making no sense.

Is it not common sense that Mueller was better than Baggio, Delpie, Klose, or any other striker to live?

No, it's common fucking sense. Look at his strike rate and awards, both personal and team oriented. He was the best striker to ever live. But apparently he isn't because I never watched him play.

Look, do whatever makes you happy, but your argument is nonsense, and any non-Delpie/Baggio fanboy would agree with me.

 

[Elvin]

WTF

Where's Molinaro, for Christ's sake? :groan:

Seriously tho, if Del broke all Scirea's records at Juve, the appearences (despite being an injury prone Supporting Striker) and titles won (he won everything except UEFA Cup, no big deal), also he's club's top scorer, won the WC also, and didn't miss his PK in the final (unlike some), I don't understand why some people ridicule the ones voting for him..
Plus, could Baggio become Capocannoniere at 33-34? Ich dont tink zo

Maybe it takes a player to retire before his true value becomes clearer eh.

 

[bianconero]

WTF

Where's Molinaro, for Christ's sake? :groan:

Seriously tho, if Del broke all Scirea's records at Juve, the appearences (despite being an injury prone Supporting Striker) and titles won (he won everything except UEFA Cup, no big deal), also he's club's top scorer, won the WC also, and didn't miss his PK in the final (unlike some), I don't understand why some people ridicule the ones voting for him..
Plus, could Baggio become Capocannoniere at 33-34? Ich dont tink zo

Maybe it takes a player to retire before his true value becomes clearer eh.

Good points well put.

 

[ßöмßäяðîëя]

Seriously tho, if Del broke all Scirea's records at Juve, the appearences (despite being an injury prone Supporting Striker) and titles won (he won everything except UEFA Cup, no big deal), also he's club's top scorer, won the WC also, and didn't miss his PK in the final (unlike some), I don't understand why some people ridicule the ones voting for him..
Plus, could Baggio become Capocannoniere at 33-34? Ich dont tink zo

Maybe it takes a player to retire before his true value becomes clearer eh.

 

[Lawnchair Bes]

if del piero had invented the role of the supporting striker that also scores goals he would have had a huge case

 

[Azzurri7]

Fred and the Elvy explained it all.

 

[ßöмßäяðîëя]

And failed at it...

You guys all have a flawed explanation.

 

[Azzurri7]

Delpie is the king at the end of the day

 

[ßöмßäяðîëя]

Maybe in your myopic eyes.

 

[Vinman]

Baggio.....

all he's missing is a WC winners medal :frown:

 

[ßöмßäяðîëя]

Should have called him and asked him why he choked it up then.

The greatest players don't choke when all the pressure is on them, in my opinion.

 

[Maher]

many of the greating players waisted PK , that did not mean that they are not great

 

[HelterSkelter]

WTF

Where's Molinaro, for Christ's sake? :groan:

Seriously tho, if Del broke all Scirea's records at Juve, the appearences (despite being an injury prone Supporting Striker) and titles won (he won everything except UEFA Cup, no big deal), also he's club's top scorer, won the WC also, and didn't miss his PK in the final (unlike some), I don't understand why some people ridicule the ones voting for him..
Plus, could Baggio become Capocannoniere at 33-34? Ich dont tink zo

Maybe it takes a player to retire before his true value becomes clearer eh.

:rofl2:

 

[Maher]

anyone who saw baggio in the 90s will know why that he cant be compared to any other italian player

 

[bianconero]

anyone who saw baggio in the 90s will know why that he cant be compared to any other italian player

I saw him and he was everyhing and more. Among the giants of the game.