I may not agree with everything you say, but you are a quality poster, and this post was full of insights. As a somewhat of bystander on the whole issue, I guess I may have overlooked this North vs South thing in the whole affair. As I have said earlier, I cannot believe health being the reason as to why Totti decided to hang up his boot for the Nazionale. If Italia didnt win WC, you have retired from International soccer games? I highly doubt it. The reason I think he decided to quit is that he feels there is nothing to prove to Italian public or world at large. He won the biggest competition in the world, he went to final of second most important only to loose at the last second of the game. Obviously weighing this up with the potential criticism which will be aimed at him for every missed pass, shot, or yellow cards playing against Lithuania, Scotland, and Georgia, you understand why he wanted to quit. Furthermore, with the birth of new child, and the age he finds himself now, I guess he would like to spend a week or two with his family without any professional stress instead of spending nights on hotels and team camps.
But in spite of all this, I have no doubts that Totti should not have quit the team. I still feel he owes the world a true master-class performance, which undoubtedly can deliver. As an avid watcher of Serie A for many years, I know what he is capable of what. I feel in form Totti is every bit as good as Rivaldo and Figo, even though, not as good as Zizou. But there are many doubts from those, who only get to see, odd game or two of him playing for Roma in CL, and Azzurri. How can people judge a player from a sample of 5-6 games I dont know. But with publicity surrounds soccer, and existence of thousands of so called "experts" trying to come up some unconventional view, you won't find shortage of people trying to belittle players game (I do that myself a bit, but at least my view don't get further away from Juventuz.com). Totti hasn't left any individual sporting outcome like Baggio, Riva, Rossi et al. In fact, the decision to retire, signifies the problem of Totti as a professional; his lack of passion to win it all. If he was so charged up about winning trophies and collecting personal accolades he would have left Roma ages ago, and kept playing Nazionale. But he doesn't. And somewhere in me says that in fact Francesco is too much of good person in heart to say no to Roma and do what is in fact best of his interest. Secondly, it will be grossly unfair to fellow professional to say I changed my mind, and I shall play for Azzurri in the Finals stage of competition. Even if he doesnt seriously intend to do so, the media pressure will be huge (e.g Maldini case), and such interest won't be healthy for the team. You know all top players should pack up their bag, and say, call me up, when things really get important. But of course they don't since if that happens talia won't qualify for the real thing. Lastly, good professional should take criticism as well as praises. They are "public figure" which means they will be a subject of scrutiny which most of us won't suffer. But to concentrate on the criticism is to see one side of the coin whilst ignoring the other. Because they are public figure, they earn millions of dollars in year, which probably all of us here won't earn even in our life time. You know, if somebody told me that I am going to earn like 10-15m dollars a year (probably more for Totti), and I get to play the game I love and receive some praise (which Totti do get) then I wouldnt mind some criticisms and slurs aimed at me. I never understood why sportsmen would ever read newspapers. Its not as if they are going to or need to read issues in Iraq, interest rate, government expenditure. Get a good taxman, PR and investment consultant then your life is pretty much sorted.
I totally agree with you some of press have their own agendas and they are vile. But I believe Totti should have made choice not to give them a good middle finger, but considering what his actions would mean to true Azzurri fans and most importantly his teammates. Quitting simply wasnt a right choice IMO.