For as long as I've been here I have complained about our HG situation. I won't print it all out again, but make a small vent that we are cutting our legs each year and it remains beyond my comprehension why we have not dealt with it after a decade.
Now... I want to ventilate something I think have already been discussed and analysed more elegantly by others here. But I still need to vent because I have literally nowhere else in my life to do it.
So...
For the past years I've complained about the lack of a midfielder with quality and grinta. A new Davids or Vidal. Now we're signing the hugely average Ramsey. Not that he is signed to close that gap, but he will not add anything that we already have. That signing makes no sense to me whatsoever. Matuidi is a great player that I have huge respect for, he makes runs to open up space for others and he chases down balls like few others. I can only speculate but I am guessing he is a really annoying player to face and a wonderful one to play with. Now the however part, as everyone can see, he offers little value with the ball at his feet. Past month he has also looked extremely drained (like our entire team). If we look only at his position and surroundings we seem to favour a midfield of Pjanic as sitting deep playmaker. Which this year is a fancy title for "pass the ball sideways". Because Pjanic cannot hold a midfield together with only one other CM (and I am not blaming him for that) we've favoured deploying Khedira when he's fit. Khedira is not as bad as others make him out to be, if his finishing was as good as Marchisio's we would see a lot more love coming his way.
Nevertheless, one thought based on the midfield we've played this year is that with Bonucci rarely going for the long breaking ball in the past months and with Pjanic (being out of steam?) playing it sideways (Pirlo's eyes must hurt) we force Dybala to drop extremely deep to fulfill, basically, Pjanic's duties. For the past month whenever we have the ball we are shaped with two CBs on the centre half, our LB and RB a bit further up down the lines, Pjanic sitting somewhere above CBs and being screened out. Dybala dropping deep up and about Pjanic's nose. Then there's a huge gap. Another huge gap. And then we have Matuidi running a little bit here and there because we have absolutely no clue on how to own spaces on the pitch and move about. We have Bentancur sprinting up to opposition CBs. Realising nothing is happening. Slowly pacing back and restarting his run. Mandz is waiting about the box and after a while gets bored and walks towards a random sideline. Ronaldo makes clever runs but no one dares passing the ball forwards or take risks. Costa/whoever else is playing tries to beat their guy whenever they get the opportunity (and I am happy they do it), because there is literally not much else going on.
I haven't checked that stats and happy to be proven wrong but my guess is that we seldom pass the ball more that our opponents. I don't want tiki taka, meaningless passes just because or triangles of nothingness. But what I see is a team with partly very little idea of how to transition spaces on the pitch and partly skill to make the transition happen anyway. Right now the transition happens when (1) the opponents make and error, (2) Dybala drops deep and gets past his man or destroyed and wins a FK, or (3) we give the ball to Cancelo so that he can make the transition happen anyway. Before him, we gave it to Costa but in a similar vein they tend to make the transition only happen on the lines of the pitch. Likewise with Cuadrado. Previously, as implied earlier, we make it with Pirlo, Vidal, Pogba. Pirlo make it happen with a pass to a FORWARD running player (it rarely happens we pass the ball in front of a moving player). Vidal just owned his space and bulldozed forward whenever it was required. Pogba dribbled his way and the gap he left behind him has not been filled. I think the "lack of passes" and especially the risky passes forward, the slow play and so on is just what happens when we do not know how to transition and own spaces on the pitch. I won't solely blame Allegri - I think that should go around to the players as well and equally much to the rest of the management. Kicking out Allegri might help but I really do not think it would bring any more success than with him. To me it seems more likely it would bring less success.
Why? Because in previous years we've had a fairly arranged game plan that was predictable but difficult to defend against. Pjanic was formidable then (and allowed?) and make nice through balls and just make the game tick. He is still important because he is still the glue to our midfield and able to hold on to the ball but as I see it we need two new midfielders. One bulldozer that has some ability with the ball and not just off the ball, and one that move the ball (basically dribble) his way from deep to open up space. We cannot sign anyone right now so my proposal is to play a midfield of Pjanic, Bentancur and Bernardeschi, and ask Bentancur to help protect Pjanic a bit. Since we do not have a bottomless pit of money next summer (or ever, of course) I want us to splash everything on a new Pogba. Then we can bring back Matuidi and play "Pogba", Pjanic and Matuidi in midfield. And no... I have no suggestions on who... just splash the budget on whoever we see fit and then start looking at future CB for the mercato in two years.