++ [ originally posted by Dominic ] ++
"holding the midfield together" Might not've been the best choise of words, I simply meant to say Camoranesi has been the leader of our midfield of our midfield this season, not Emerson.
Again, perhaps Camoranesi is the leader of our midfield going forward, however who held the midfield together defensively? Who made up for the mistakes of the other midfielders around him? Who rarely gave the ball away to the opposing team and never was caught out of position?
That's something I cannot answer, noone can say how we would've done if Emerson had not played all season. My point is not that we are better without Emerson, not at all. I never said Emerson is a bad player and I admitted that he helps our defence out a great deal. I'm simply stating that Emerson is a player who we'd be able to replace.
Not with this current team, you know, what we are talking about now. Zebina, Thuram, Zambrotta, Appiah, Blasi, Tacchinardi, Kapo, Nedved, Montero, Ferrara, Pessotto, Birindelli, Zalayeta, and Buffon can all easily be "replaced" this summer. Everybody could be "replaced."
I do not take kindly to personal insults.
How can Emerson be underrated, when he is rated so highly?
That was not a dig at you my friend, however I see too many people looking over the small things that players do. Much like Albelda of Valencia, Gattuso of Milan, and every defensive midfielder that has played at Madrid in the past few years. Not all notice small things.
I've rated Zebina in my top five as he has performed incredibly well this season, despite us expecting relatively little of him(this also applies to Zalayeta etc.). Next to Camoranesi, our best asset this season has been our defence; Zebina is part of that defence. That's also a reason why 'nominated' Pessotto, when he deputised for Zebina he made a great contribution to our already good defence. I also wrote that I'd like to include Emerson to my runner-ups.
Who'd replace Emerson? Well, that'd happen if we'd sell him, we'd only sell him for some big bucks and with those big bucks we could easily get TWO great central midfielders.
You know who also made a huge contribution to the defense? His name is Emerson. Many times during the season he has had to backtrack to Zebina's right side of the pitch to help the latter out from getting owned. Sure, Zebina has had a better season than most would've thought, but is that a reason to mention him instead of player who has done more for the team and is not replaceable with our current squad? Zebina can easily be replaced by Pessotto, but what about Blasi for Emerson? Surely you see a difference, a big difference.
Sure, we can replace Emerson with Vieira or Essien, but why would we do that? That would be dumb business considering the price we would recieve for Emerson and the fact we actually don't need a replacement because he's good enough.