The 4-yr. old Preacher (5 Viewers)

[IrishZebra]

He does have a right to believe it, that's obvious.

However, some might say that it's irrational to believe in something without evidence.

That's precisely the point of the (fairies/bigfoot/the creature you want) example.

Ah yes, but it only becomes a problem when he says God is Fact, not I believe in God. All beliefs, if espoused, are open to ridicule.

 

Buy on AliExpress.com

[AndreaCristiano]

Ok, so I could invent with my imagination a monster with the head of Motta, the hairs of Amauri and the body of Miccoli, say that it exists ,and you would not disbelieve its existence despite the lack of evidence on its existence?

If you truly believed it and truly said you saw it , who am I to disbelieve your senses?

 

[AndreaCristiano]

Ah yes, but it only becomes a problem when he says God is Fact, not I believe in God. All beliefs, if espoused, are open to ridicule.

Well for me belief in God is a fact, otherwise I wouldnt believe now would I

 

[Trequartista]

there is no evidence for your soul are you saying you dont have one?

There is no evidence that souls exist and therefore I have to reject the proposition that I have a soul.

 

[AndreaCristiano]

It's easy for you to respect others, because it gives you great satisfaction knowing that is going to help you into the presence of the almighty.

Do mad people who commit vile crimes go to heaven?

No hitler doesnt go to heaven

 

[IrishZebra]

Yes but you don't go about saying, My God is the real and only god, Fact, undeniable.

 

[Trequartista]

Ah yes, but it only becomes a problem when he says God is Fact, not I believe in God. All beliefs, if espoused, are open to ridicule.

True.

 

[Trequartista]

If you truly believed it and truly said you saw it , who am I to disbelieve your senses?

It is the same thing with personal experiences of revelation.

One can say that he talked with God but he has no way of proving that it's true to other people and since he cannot produce evidence that he did, rational people should not believe that that person had a revelation.

It's a simple application of the scientific method and rational thinking.

 

[bianconero]

No hitler doesnt go to heaven

Answer the question: In your philosophy do mad people who commit sins of a vile nature go ti heaven?

 

[AndreaCristiano]

There is no evidence that souls exist and therefore I have to reject the proposition that I have a soul.

Well thats just insane, I feel my soul, essence , chi whatever you like to call it and to say it doesnt exist because their is no evidence is silly to say the least

 

[Trequartista]

Well thats just insane, I feel my soul, essence , chi whatever you like to call it and to say it doesnt exist because their is no evidence is silly to say the least

Is it sillier than believing people who say that they had a revelation?

 

[AndreaCristiano]

Answer the question: In your philosophy do mad people who commit sins of a vile nature go ti heaven?

I did. If your gonna be an ass I will no longer discuss this with you

 

[AndreaCristiano]

Is it sillier than believing people who say that they had a revelation?

No some people actually have revelations

 

[Trequartista]

No some people actually have revelations

How do you know?

 

[AndreaCristiano]

Yes but you don't go about saying, My God is the real and only god, Fact, undeniable.

if you ask me that will be my answer im not gonna sugar coat my beliefs for anyone

 

[bianconero]

I did. If your gonna be an ass I will no longer discuss this with you

So the god you believe in, will damn those who are mad-seriously ill in other words? Is this the god of love and compassion. As well as those who have heard of Jesus but rejected him?

Serious question.

 

[JuveJay]

Well thats just insane, I feel my soul, essence , chi whatever you like to call it and to say it doesnt exist because their is no evidence is silly to say the least

The human brain is a lot more complex than just being able to do the normal tasks we understand it to do.

 

[AndreaCristiano]

How do you know?

just lets say i do, its a bit personal and dont feel like being ridiculed

 

[AndreaCristiano]

The human brain is a lot more complex than just being able to do the normal tasks we understand it to do.

thats my point, there is so much we dont know so how can one say because there is no evidence it doesnt exist

 

[IrishZebra]

if you ask me that will be my answer im not gonna sugar coat my beliefs for anyone

You view them as beliefs though you make that clear at least?