Player ratings after each match (11 Viewers)

[Lawnchair Bes]

i was thinkin that it would be easier to find the posts. everytime i dont see a game i try to look for a review from you or vinni, or whomever that takes time to write an in depth review and it always takes time finding it

 

Buy on AliExpress.com

[Bjerknes]

i was thinkin that it would be easier to find the posts. everytime i dont see a game i try to look for a review from you or vinni, or whomever that takes time to write an in depth review and it always takes time finding it

Well, we could always make a closed thread filled with specific member's match reports...that is another easy job to do.

 

[Lawnchair Bes]

that sounds like a nice idea

 

[swag]

Not to overcomplicate the suggestions here, but I do like what The Don recommends here. In those matches I don't get to see (and even in the ones I do), it would be ideal to have a quick way to reference the player ratings and commentary (I do like explanations as to why players got the ratings they received) filed by a number of posters in one convenient place. Otherwise it's about fishing through them in long post-match threads.

 

[Lawnchair Bes]

i was thinking, whomever wants to post a report can pm it to a mod, who then can evaluate if it is "adequate" (biases are not that important) and post it on a closed thread

 

[swag]

I'm more than willing to help facilitate that.

 

[Bjerknes]

Alright, we can select the match reports of the most objective posters and either place them in a closed thread or in a specific section of the forum, such as where Marty puts the juventus.com match reports which arent that good anyway.

 

[Lawnchair Bes]

plus i think we would all agree with swag's definition of adequate.

 

[JCK]

I think this thread with specific posts is a great idea. I and other members fill the match thread with totally unwanted crap and it sure does distract those who haven't seen the game and followed the action.

 

[Marty]

This is very interesting, thanks for all the input everyone. It would indeed be cool to have our own Match Reports rather than Juventus.com official match reports only. Matched with our player ratings and member views this would be a great addition to the site, and it could be created as a news on the main post as well as a forum thread for discussion.

 

[Dominic]

Though wouldn't it take away from the discussions, seperating everything?

 

[Bjerknes]

Though wouldn't it take away from the discussions, seperating everything?

Not really, as the reports would appear in both the match thread and locked section of the forum. At least that is the way I see it.

 

[swag]

Yes. I see it as just a way to highlight some of our better member "editorial" and ratings unique to us (i.e., Juventuz) -- in a way that's not buried in the back-and-forth that goes on in a typical post-match thread.

 

[swag]

Another thought...
and I only mention this in case this is something relatively brain dead to do with vB3, Marty ...
maybe there's an easy vB3 way to merely allow mods to check off and highlight certain posts in a post-match thread -- and then copy them or (better?) enable filtering on them so that they can be made more visible to others.

 

[Seven]

IMO either one of those fifteen should write a match report, given that they saw that particular game (which they probably did). You aren't going to rate a player with no particular reason to give him that rating, you'll always need to explain yourself as well. It's not that much extra work to write a match report while you're at it.

 

[Dragon]

I forgot Baggio! He should be in there if he gets regular coverage

 

[Seven]

Perhaps we could use Juventus-Treviso as a testrun?

 

[JCK]

What about creating a journal?

We can collect writings, not only match reports, articles, opinions anything like that. The can be collected and summed up in one pdf in a proper layout. I think this will be amazing, our own publications. We need a proofreader and an editor, the members submit their articles and that's it.

 

[Lawnchair Bes]

perhaps

 

[Martin]

What about creating a journal?

We can collect writings, not only match reports, articles, opinions anything like that. The can be collected and summed up in one pdf in a proper layout. I think this will be amazing, our own publications. We need a proofreader and an editor, the members submit their articles and that's it.

This sounds really cool!