Vidal was piss poor at some big games (CL final most noteably), and Pogba was great in a lot of important games (see the zizinho post).
Yes, over the course of their seasons here Vidal had more big games than Pogba, but the former was in his prime and the latter was a fucking kid for the majority of it and is now two years younger than Vidal was when he joined us.
This argument is stupid.
Vidal was our best midfielder untill his last season, which he started injured. He grew back to his defensive form, and was vidal in reaching the final. In which he had a horrible game.
'piss poor at some big games' is just flat out lying. You are talking about ONE big game.
Pogba was never 'great' in big games except the Man City game. He was good, but he was never the best midfield player for juventus, let alone carry the midfield.
Your post is stupid. I have exceptionally clearly stated "the quality right now, not in 4-5 years". I'm purely talking about comparing our quality right now. As in right now. You know, right now.
'right now' doesnt give a shit about age. Its about right now.
So yeah, read what you are quoting ffs.
The point was : people say our midfield turned weak now. Absolutely not. The midfield potential, took a hit. But if we get herrera, the midfield quality RIGHT NOW, is just every bit as good as it was.
Its about comparing our chances for a cl the comming season. So its about right now. Not in 4-5 years time. Right now
Got it @Ocelot ? right now.
- - - Updated - - -
Maybe not, but why are we comparing a 29 year old in his prime to a player still developing who is still only 23?!
Plus, Pogba has a much higher ceiling and potential than Vidal.
Thats not the point.
People said our midfield weakens now.
my point is, right now if we get herrera it doesnt weaken at all. it just loses its potential to grow