Movie Talk (New Films, Old Films... doesn't matter) (62 Viewers)

[king Ale]

Inglourious Basterds.

A very thrilling and entertaining movie but I think Tarantino screwed it up towards the end. I don't mind him contorting the history and I don't mind Hitler getting killed like that but first: there must be a logical and believable reason for Hitler attending such a show without proper security guards. I mean how the hell do they let two Italian filmmakers get into the saloon where Hitler is present? How the hell don't they check on the smallest details before Hitler coming there? It wasn't supposed to be a comical Scary Movie but it struck me as one at times.

Second: Why on earth Tarantino changed the Walts character so drastically in the end? Germans believed that they were going to win the war so why on earth should Walts think about helping the Allies right when he has everything under control? How is this logically acceptable for a supposing intelligent man like him to trust Aldo in the end?

With a better ending it would have been a much better movie. 7/10 for me.

 

Buy on AliExpress.com

[Elvin]

Hoori, your mistake is expecting logic in a Tarantino movie. This guy is all about entertainment and the awesomeness factor.

 

[king Ale]

Well it sucks. He says his idols are Scorsese and Kubrick but he will never be even close to them if he doesn't make his films believable. He's been on a downfall since Pulp Fiction. Inglourious Basterds was sure much better than Grindhouse and Death Proof but it was nowhere near the greatness of Pulp Fiction IMO.

 

[GordoDeCentral]

samurai rebellion- Classic!

 

[Bisco]

Inglourious Basterds.

A very thrilling and entertaining movie but I think Tarantino screwed it up towards the end. I don't mind him contorting the history and I don't mind Hitler getting killed like that but first: there must be a logical and believable reason for Hitler attending such a show without proper security guards. I mean how the hell do they let two Italian filmmakers get into the saloon where Hitler is present? How the hell don't they check on the smallest details before Hitler coming there? It wasn't supposed to be a comical Scary Movie but it struck me as one at times.

Second: Why on earth Tarantino changed the Walts character so drastically in the end? Germans believed that they were going to win the war so why on earth should Walts think about helping the Allies right when he has everything under control? How is this logically acceptable for a supposing intelligent man like him to trust Aldo in the end?

With a better ending it would have been a much better movie. 7/10 for me.

i do agree with yr take on the story hoori and when u refer to walts i think u should add that it made the killing of Bridget von Hammersmark quite pointless bec at the end of the day he himself sold his allegiance.

it could've made sense if tarantino did not build up the "ideal solider" characteristic that walts had and the reputation he had. so this move really canceled out the first scene of the movie where walts was looking for the jews hiding under the floor board of the french mans house.

 

[blondu]

stick to porn comments man

 

[Lawnchair Bes]

Inglourious Basterds.

A very thrilling and entertaining movie but I think Tarantino screwed it up towards the end. I don't mind him contorting the history and I don't mind Hitler getting killed like that but first: there must be a logical and believable reason for Hitler attending such a show without proper security guards. I mean how the hell do they let two Italian filmmakers get into the saloon where Hitler is present? How the hell don't they check on the smallest details before Hitler coming there? It wasn't supposed to be a comical Scary Movie but it struck me as one at times.

Second: Why on earth Tarantino changed the Walts character so drastically in the end? Germans believed that they were going to win the war so why on earth should Walts think about helping the Allies right when he has everything under control? How is this logically acceptable for a supposing intelligent man like him to trust Aldo in the end?

With a better ending it would have been a much better movie. 7/10 for me.

italians and germans were allies in wwii, plus, hitler was betrayed by his head of security.

the thing about walts, is that he was very very very smart. he realized the germans would never win and he found a way to get on top again.

 

[king Ale]

I was talking about "The Allies". If you already noticed that, I think you need to take some history lessons then

 

[Lawnchair Bes]

what you talking about

 

[king Ale]

Italians and Germans were the Allies in WWII?

 

[Lawnchair Bes]

yeah, they were. until italy started losing that is

 

[mikhail]

They were allies, not "The Allies".

 

[king Ale]

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Allies_of_World_War_II

 

[Lawnchair Bes]

oh jeez, i didnt notice the capitalization, and its implications. my bad. but it is my understanding that they were fighting together, along with austria-hungary

 

[mikhail]

oh jeez, i didnt notice the capitalization, and its implications. my bad. but it is my understanding that they were fighting together, along with austria-hungary

Austria-Hungary was WWI. Austria was part of Germany during WWII (Anschluss). Hungary were kind of reluctant allies of Germany at that time.

Anyway, Bes' point earlier stands. Italians wouldn't have found it any harder to get near Hitler than regular Germans.

 

[Lawnchair Bes]

oh yes

 

[Bisco]

stick to porn comments man

yeah who cares about the script or story in those movies

 

[SABSAB]

Hitler worked after the example of Mussolini.

BTW, I remember in school, history class, I wanted to say something about Mussolini and said Moratti...

 

[Elvin]

oh jeez, i didnt notice the capitalization, and its implications. my bad. but it is my understanding that they were fighting together, along with austria-hungary

No waaay... You of all people?

 

[Lawnchair Bes]

are you referring to my "L" incident a couple of years back?