Movie Talk (New Films, Old Films... doesn't matter) (38 Viewers)

[Ahmed]

Jinnah -

 

Buy on AliExpress.com

[Tommy]

Jinnah -

Hindi??
UP - wonderful movie

 

[Ahmed]

English

 

[Tommy]

I'm halfway through Der Untergang. Gonna watch the rest now. Seems to be a very good one

 

[IrishZebra]

I found it very good but overrated, the one with Robbie Carlyle in it is miles better.

http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0346293/

 

[Buck Fuddy]

I'm halfway through Der Untergang. Gonna watch the rest now. Seems to be a very good one

I found it very good but overrated, the one with Robbie Carlyle in it is miles better.

http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0346293/

Both are ok, pretty good even. But they are not great. Especially Der Untergang was rather overrated.

 

[Tommy]

I found it very good but overrated, the one with Robbie Carlyle in it is miles better.

http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0346293/

both had different concepts though

 

[IrishZebra]

both had different concepts though

Ah yes but Carlyles one is about the growth of hitler as a maniac, downfall is basically a schizo breakdown drama.

 

[Ford Prefect]

bestest film about hitler is "downfall"

 

[IrishZebra]

bestest film about hitler is "downfall"

No

 

[Ford Prefect]

No

The ITV one with Carlyse was too poetic and used a lot of artistic license, Downfall/Der Untergang used historic accounts and was focused on a few days rather than the whole regime. Its like comparing an in depth match report of injury time or watching the highlights on MOTD.

 

[IrishZebra]

The ITV one with Carlyse was too poetic and used a lot of artistic license, Downfall/Der Untergang used historic accounts and was focused on a few days rather than the whole regime. Its like comparing an in depth match report of injury time or watching the highlights on MOTD.

Yeah sure, the best film about hitler is one that focuses on the last few weeks of his life, and not the events that lead up to the whole reign of hitler and the reign itself....good luck with that

 

[Ford Prefect]

Yeah sure, the best film about hitler is one that focuses on the last few weeks of his life, and not the events that lead up to the whole reign of hitler and the reign itself....good luck with that

The first one wasnt a film, it was a tv documentary and i was trying to say, they are two different things.

 

[IrishZebra]

The first one wasnt a film, it was a tv documentary and i was trying to say, they are two different things.

So you're saying the best film about Hitler is the one that isn't a factually objective, real-world presentation?(Untergang)

Depends really on what you term a documentary, I mean not just becuase its on TV and broken into parts you know?

 

[Ford Prefect]

So you're saying the best film about Hitler is the one that isn't a factually objective, real-world presentation?(Untergang)

Depends really on what you term a documentary, I mean not just becuase its on TV and broken into parts you know?

Downfall is as factually accurate as they could get it, its based on interviews, journals, recordings etc.etc. from the last few days. The ITV TV Film/dramatised documentary is loosely based on facts and used a lot of artistic licence, we had to study it when i was 15 at school as a test to see if we could spot the inaccuracies.

 

[IrishZebra]

Downfall is as factually accurate as they could get it, its based on interviews, journals, recordings etc.etc. from the last few days. The ITV TV Film/dramatised documentary is loosely based on facts and used a lot of artistic licence, we had to study it when i was 15 at school as a test to see if we could spot the inaccuracies.

So neither of us defines it as a 'documentary' then?

good.

 

[Quetzalcoatl]

I just spent over an hour watching "Paranormal Activity" thinking that it was supposed to be real events (that's what the person who lent me the movie told me) becuase that would have been the only justification for how lame the movie is otherwise, only to google it and find that it's a scripted movie with actors.

 

[IrishZebra]

I just spent over an hour watching "Paranormal Activity" thinking that it was supposed to be real events (that's what the person who lent me the movie told me) becuase that would have been the only justification for how lame the movie is otherwise, only to google it and find that it's a scripted movie with actors.

You fell for the based on ture events line?

 

[Fred]

Watched "Beyond Reasonable Doubt" yesterday in the cinema. Decent flick, unexpected ending.

 

[Martin]

Public Enemies

Quite good, but didn't really succeed at pulling me in.

EDIT: Marion Cotillard deserves a big