Medhi Benatia - CB - Bayern Munich (27 Viewers)

[Hust]

What's rugani for, kid deserves his chance, Nd benatia too expensive to be just a sub

- - - Updated - - -



We don't need a starting CB

Personally I think Benatia and Rugani are being lined up to take over for the aging Barzagli and eventual Chiellini decline. One injury prone and one is on the wrong side of age. It would be amazing depth to keep our main back 3 cued up for CL ties and the big league matches.

Marotta said 2 key players for each position so its obvious Rugani is behind one of the back 3 with Benatia being being another.

 

Buy on AliExpress.com

[lgorTudor]

do not want

 

[Hust]

We don't need a starting CB

But you need one good enough to be a starter when one goes down. Do we want another Ogbonna? Nah, no thank you.

 

[GordoDeCentral]

But you need one good enough to be a starter when one goes down. Do we want another Ogbonna? Nah, no thank you.

 

[zizinho]

1m loan plus 20m option next year to be cover with Coman money it would be an awesome deal cuz if he's good we keep him cheap and if he doesn't, we get 20m

less than 20M, around 16

 

[The Quazis]

I agree with Hustini. Not so long ago Barzagli was out for an entire season. The fact he was fit all the time recently cannot be taken for granted. We usually play with 3 CBs, we can't only have Rugani as backup. Plus, Chiellini is very injury prone and receives a lot of yellows.

Loan + option is a nobrainer.

 

[GordoDeCentral]

I agree with Hustini. Not so long ago Barzagli was out for an entire season. The fact he was fit all the time recently cannot be taken for granted. We usually play with 3 CBs, we can't only have Rugani as backup. Plus, Chiellini is very injury prone and receives a lot of yellows.

Loan + option is a nobrainer.

You are right let's have starters back up all our starters just in case

 

[The Quazis]

You are right let's have starters back up all our starters just in case

So we only bought Pjanic because of Marchisio's injury? Otherwise we would have Khedira-Marchisio-Pogba, where does Pjanic fit? And going with your logic, when Marchisio comes back we sell one of the before mentioned players?

 

[Hust]

I agree with Hustini. Not so long ago Barzagli was out for an entire season. The fact he was fit all the time recently cannot be taken for granted. We usually play with 3 CBs, we can't only have Rugani as backup. Plus, Chiellini is very injury prone and receives a lot of yellows.

Loan + option is a nobrainer.

Barzagli might not be able to handle 3 competitions next year. We know already Chiellini is good for at least 2 injuries and god forbid we have another 60+ injury season next year.

Caceres is leaving we know so that means we need a strong CB. Most of the players on the bench of Real & Barca can walk into just about any team in Europe with the exception of a very small number even then its still debatable.

If we want to be a top 3 club we need a top 3 bench.

- - - Updated - - -

So we only bought Pjanic because of Marchisio's injury? Otherwise we would have Khedira-Marchisio-Pogba, where does Pjanic fit? And going with your logic, when Marchisio comes back we sell one of the before mentioned players?

Good point

 

[KB824]

You are right let's have starters back up all our starters just in case

They do need another central defender though. Having four in a 3-5-2 formation is asking for trouble. Do they need a Benatia quality 5th CB? Probably not. That is a little too pricey, unless the price is just too good to pass up

 

[Hydde]

If we can get him on or terms without making too much of a sacrifice, he would come good.

It depends on what formation allegri wants to use more. If we are into heavy 352, another CB is a must,, because last season we overplayed Bonucci and Barzagli, and Chiello and barza could be injured for a considerable amount of time between the 2.

Rugani and another dude are needed just in case.

 

[Kopanja]

If there is a loan with no obligation (which is unlikely) do it. If loan+buy and price is ok do it.
He is no young and green though, 29 years.

 

[GordoDeCentral]

They do need another central defender though. Having four in a 3-5-2 formation is asking for trouble. Do they need a Benatia quality 5th CB? Probably not. That is a little too pricey, unless the price is just too good to pass up

Id still pass it up, rugani has to be the go to guy in rotation, like you said what we need a 5th CB and rugani shouldnt be it

 

[Jem83]

If there is a loan with no obligation (which is unlikely) do it. If loan+buy and price is ok do it.
He is no young and green though, 29 years.

Not that high for a CB. Can be at maximum level for 5-6 more years.

 

[ladstone]

benatia ang gotze, less than 40M will be a good deal

 

[juventus4life]

Id still pass it up, rugani has to be the go to guy in rotation, like you said what we need a 5th CB and rugani shouldnt be it

Only Rugani as a back up for all three BBC is just simply not enough. Especially we play with 3 in the back. Suspension, injuries will jeopardize our chance in CL.

 

[GordoDeCentral]

Only Rugani as a back up for all three BBC is just simply not enough. Especially we play with 3 in the back. Suspension, injuries will jeopardize our chance in CL.

I'm pretty sure this was in the post you quoted "we need a 5th CB"

 

[Disorder]

if he's cheap or we could get him on loan we should do it. chiellini and barzagli won't play every game and caceres is leaving. We have 4 players for 3 positions, if someone is injured or suspended at CL knockout phase we're fucked.

 

[juventus4life]

The new Caceres

 

[Ocelot]

I'm pretty sure this was in the post you quoted "we need a 5th CB"

And if he's cheap Benatia is a great fit for that role, especially considering that we're gonna need a Barzagli replacement in a year or two, when he decides to hang up his boots and find the cure for cancer instead. And we're gonna need four top class CBs for a three man backline.

We just shouldn't overpay, but if he's offered to us on a good deal he would be a great addition.