Again, not a lawyer, but isn't the main question whether Allegri breached his contract or not? And then if he did and it can be proved, the next question probably is whether rescinding contract is an adequate response to that breach. I understand that the defense would build the case around Allegri's fate being determined months before, but if the facts are there and they can be proved, I don't see why the court would have to consider intent, unless there's reason to believe the club actually manipulated Allegri and pushed him towards this.
- - - Updated - - -
If we punish Allegri's antics on the touchline or post match with the directors I completely agree, that's ridiculous, you could find film for every coach getting emotional on the touchline or yelling at the ref.
However if the altercation with Tuttosport guy went down as the guy says, that's not an everyday situation, that's something not acceptable that Allegri created all by himself.