To perform when it matters the most. Simple as that.
Ah.
So the entire Serie A season, despite those decisive goals to give us 3 points to keep the team at the top and earn that trophy/medal at the end of the season....nope, doesn't count.
Because no final was played where he could score the "winning" goal to make him the sole winner and the remaining players simply participated in that final.
I'm starting to understand the logic. He didn't perform when it mattered over the course of an entire season to help the team (in a team game) advance.
Well. I'll be damned. We have zero winners in our current team.
We're doing it wrong.