No, I'm not. He's basing his argument on a legitimate connection. In the case of a country, that legitimate connection is nationality. In case of a club it's more difficult to tell, but the legitimate connection is not not seeing ONE game of your club live. I mean, you have to do better than that.
Andy's only argument was about national teams. national teams are meant to represent nations and only that given country's citizens can play for that nation. Clubs are different and almost anybody can play for a given club.
Now i'm not saying that i agree with Andy. I'm just saying that you're twisting his arguments by bringing in that "you have to watch your club live" thing.
