++ [ originally posted by Tom ] ++
I'd be interested to get an Indian perspective on this actually but why do you rate Sachin as better than Dravid? Imo Rahul has got to be the most consistent batsman in world cricket. I know your list has a coupla past players in as well, but whats your current top 5?
Btw Freddy Flintoff should be in your top 5 bowlers and arguably batsmen as well.
You're right Tom, Dravid has got what it takes to topple Sachin from that number 1 spot, except perhaps, the statistics. I think Dravid is probably the most mentally prepared bat in the world, but Sachin is by far and away the most devastating on his day. As Axl pointed out above, Sachin is more loved because he's sort of been the face of Indian cricket so to speak, over the past decade. But I think i'll point out here, that he no longer enjoys the kind of god like status hes being made out to enjoy, because like i said previously, the game today is all about your ability in the facets of the game. And with the kind of all rounders developing today, I think they've taken over the mantle and responsibility Sachin was deemed to have in the past.
As for Freddy Flintoff, I cant tell you how much Im enjoying him whipping the Aussies. He's probably doing as well if not better than what Botham has done in the past for England.
My current top 5:
Batsmen
1. Dravid
2. Ponting
3. Inzimam
4. Hayden
5. Flintoff
Best all-rounder in the game currently:
1. Flintoff
I think the bowlers list was pretty contemporary and quite frankly the best line up in a century.