Well yeah, but it does happen on most forums.
The comment 'overrated' does make me smile though.
Con x 10: he's crap
Pro x 1: no he isn't
Con x 10: wow, look how overrated he is here
Normally you'd need some ratings to be overrated.
Oh yeah, it definitely happens on most forums. Lots of little cliques too, so when a couple elder statesmen start the assault, it can get a little out of control.
I guess some of the response is because a lot of the people who bash the player now, once thought that he would be world class - and now that he's struggling, they feel personally betrayed, or something like that?
Anyway, he's a useful squad player on a good salary, and it does no good to incessantly bash a useful squad member - especially one who's a youth product, and seems to have almost undying love and commitment to the jersey; as far as I can tell, he's always willing to sacrifice himself for the sake of the team.
Modern players surf the net, and they feel the overwhelming negativity surrounding the team. All the hate is counterproductive, just wasted energy IMO, especially when he's not one of our main problems.