I never said we should sell both of them in order to get Icardi.
Also, I even stated how we shouldn't play Icardi - Ronaldo.
Oh, but here's the thing. Just because some players failed in certain clubs I don't think they are shit. IMO Pogba is a good player despite his spell in England. I also think Icardi is a very good striker and possibly next to Dybala he'd bang in shitload of goals here imo. Both of them are examples where I can't say they are big fish in a small both because they succeeded at clubs like Inter and Juve.
If Allegri comes I think we're going to keep Dybala and sell Ronaldo. I also see us push for Icardi. I can't say I'll fap over such moves but I won't think it's a horrible transfer surely. I think he'd provide what is asked from him and that's goals.
I also wouldn't like to see Dybala - Morata next season, that would be cancer.
Morata-Dybala > Icardi-Dybala and it’s not close. Dybala is a goalscoring forward. His playmaking and assisting has never at Juve been a top attribute. Even alongside Higuain he was maxing out at like 7 assists, but scoring 20+ goals each year. Icardi-Dybala would be a fucking awful, piss-poor attitude and effort, slowest, most predictable in the world attack. Our midfield doesn’t control games and you think we gonna play on the counter with those two turtles?

I don’t even want to think how bad that pair would be in CL, where games play more open and faster paced.
At least Morata is a CL style forward, with some pace, and with a history of consistent scoring and big goals in the competition. And of the the three he’s the only one who has actually had a productive season, in a poor team with no coach. Icardi’s been complete shit playing for a team with Neymar and Mbappe and Di Maria creating chances. Lol
Morata this year had produced more than Icardi has in any of his past 3 seasons.
Morata for 10 mil loan + 5 mil wage > Icardi for 40-50mil transfer fee + higher wage