This my reply to a Roma fan who jumped in - observe my REFUSAL to confront facts :
I usually don’t fancy replying in a debate by quoting the other person but in this case I will have to make an exception. Let me start though by saying that if you are to “dismantle my points”, you will have to try a lot harder than that.
Quote:
Dude, I am from Rome Italy and If you dont mind I know my politics. Your post is way too long to be answered all but I will answer some main points. When you say Berlusca has all the media, crap, our media is free like any other democratic country. Do I have to remind you what papers like Unita', Repubblica, Lotta Continua etc say about Berlusca? Or how RAI 3 tells their news? pls. Berlusca is hated because he is rich. He is doing fine as a the Presidente del Consiglio. La Sinistra was in the govt before him and what did they do better? Nothing.
It is a fact that whoever is in power in Italy has the ability to control and influence public television. It shouldn’t be so, but it has always been and will probably still be like that for some time. The composition of RAI’s board is usually decided by the government of the day. The Berlusconi government is no exception to this “rule”. Indeed, the too “left-leaning” Zaccaria was promptly replaced by Saccà as President of the Board immediately after the 2001 elections. This government has gone even further though, banning satirical shows it deemed too critical as well as Enzo Biagi, who, since the great Montanelli’s demise, is acknowledged as the most authoritative Italian journalist alive. Add to this Berlusconi’s ownership of all of Italy’s private televisions (bar La Sette), and you see how Italy is the only democracy in the world where the PM has such a huge control (directly or not) of what is being shown on the screen. So when a channel with little influence such as RAI 3 tries to rebel against this state of affairs, they are of course labelled as communists.
As far as I know “Lotta Continua” is a political movement, not a newspaper. If there is such a newspaper, then I imagine its relevance must be as big as Liechtenstein’s role in world affairs, for even a careful observer of Italy’s political life like myself had never heard of it. Similarly : how many people in Italy read l'Unità? As for La Repubblica, it is the italian equivalent to the Guardian if you like, but the most read paper in Italy remains the conservative (and fairly objective) Corriere della Sera. I will come back on the “doing fine Presidente del Consiglio” part later.
Quote:
That was back in the day dude. Bossi was mostly *****ing since the nord actually does produce more than the mezzogiorno.
Did you actually bother reading what I said? Someone claimed that the first Berlusconi government fell exclusively because of Bossi. Wrong. The “coup de grâce” was the opening of an investigation on Berlusconi. One can say what he wants about Bossi, but not that he is not a man of principles. The best proof of this is that to this day he is still “*****ing since the North produces more”. The only difference is that now that he is in power he talks about “federalism” rather than downright “secession”. Roman MP’s are a more refined audience than disgruntled “padani” I suppose.
Quote:
Are you sure you are not Berinotti? Actually the whole trial against Berlusca was made up by LEFT party magistrati. Get your news straight.
Is that it ? That’s your argument ? Calling me Bertinotti? Mister “3% of the vote” Fausto Bertinotti? That’s what scares the mighty “forzisti”? I have a first news for you : communism has ceased to exist 13 years ago. And, if only, Forza Italia should thank Bertinotti for making Prodi’s government resign in ’98 by just one vote. It amazes me how Italy is still hunting “commies” after all this time. Again, it’s a very typically Italian feature it seems. I don’t see Chirac dismissing the left as communists, nor would the German opposition accuse Schroeder of serving Marxist interests. But hey, it’s Italy we are talking about : people don’t engage in proper debates with their opponents here, they try to diminish them by applying labels ad nauseam. Whoever said “If you tell a lie big enough and keep repeating it, people will eventually come to believe it”? Oh yeah, Dr Goebbels.
Anyway, let me warn you : the labelling won’t work with me. I am neither a socialist nor a conservative. I don’t follow ideologies : they’re as brainwashing as religions. Had I been old enough to vote at the time, I reckon I could have gone for the Democrazia Cristiana in the 80’s. I wish I could say that today I vote FOR the left, if only they were worth it, but the sad truth is that the only choice I have now is to vote AGAINST Forza Italia. This is why the regional and EU Parliament elections which the right is expected to lose next June will hardly be a victory for the left, but rather a defeat for the right.
Now back to the history lesson. During the Bribesville scandal in ’93, the judiciary was the only institution left trusted by Italian public opinion. A certain number of special measures were taken to allow judges to better fight omnipresent corruption. Such as the extension of the “custodia cautelare” period, i.e. the period of “preventive incarceration” of a political figure subjected to an inquiry. Preventive incarceration did indeed bear its fruit : fearing it as they did, many politicians started collaborating with the judges, giving them precious informations. Now here is my next question : what parties at the time did endorse those measures and hailed the Italian judiciary for its independence (an independence that was highly respected and envied by their European counterparts)? That’s right : Lega Nord, Alleanza Nazionale and…Forza Italia! It seems that accountability is only desirable when it helps you win an election…
Having said this, I want to make a short digression on the controversial “change of venue” law, which someone evoked and on which I forgot to elaborate in my previous post. This law enables a person that is subjected to an investigation to ask for her trial to be held in a different court if she suspects that the present one won’t give her a fair trial. After examining his request, The Supreme Court did indeed refuse to move Berlusconi’s trial from Milan to Brescia. What hasn’t been specified however is that by changing the venue, you also have to start the whole trial from scrap in the new court. Given that Berlusconi’s trial has been going on for years (notably thanks to his army of lawyers’ ability to postpone decisions), this would almost certainly have meant it would have fallen under statute of limitation. But since that law was not sufficient, here comes the immunity law!
Quote:
Again thats false. Italy since Berlusca has had better relations with all countries. We are in the G8 so I dont see why you are bragging.
If you think Italy’s stance in the world has improved, then clearly you need to get out of Italy more. Being a founding member of the EU, Italy has been one of the most reliable European partners ever since its inception. Indeed, every italian government since the Treaty of Rome in 54, be it socialist or Christian Democrat, has always stuck to its European committments. Not since Berlusca took over, that is. The man has managed to squander that hard-won trust and respectability in just 3 years. Again, this is easy to see for anyone who has frequented the EU circles long enough. Given the British’ traditional euroscepticism, France and Germany have always seen Italy as the ideal third big partner from whom to get support. Well, not anymore : these days the “directorate” is either led by France and Germany or – since enlargement – France, Germany and the UK. Not ONCE has Italy been invited to participate. We have never received such a negative coverage in the European press : hardly a week passes by without the Frankfurter Allgemein, the Financial Times or Le Monde reporting on the Italian “anomaly” – are you gonna label these papers as communist too?
To be fair, Berlusconi does have two allies on the international scene : Bush and Putin. A Christian fundamentalist from Texas and a Russian autocrat : nice way to compromise our long-standing relation with our European allies, Silvio! Incidentally, do you have any idea why our government is the only one that fiercely opposes the introduction of a European warrant of arrest? Because that would allow Courts that are trying him in other countries (such as Madrid, which is investigating on the Tele Cinqo scandal) to convict him.
The G 8? So now Italy is in the G 8 thanks to Berlusca? As far as I know we have been there since the 70’s or something, back when Berlusconi was just a successful entrepreneur affiliated to an illegal Masonic lodge. But don’t worry, seeing how dynamic Italy’s economy has been in the last 3 years Im sure we will get excluded from that club as well. I just happen to have the Economist’s Intelligence Unit’s monthly economic overview of the EU member states with me. Italy’s GDP growth in the last quarter has reached…0,1%! We’re dead last of the list : is this the economic miracle we were promised in the campaign?
Quote:
La sinistra Italiana tried and succeded to get Berlusca out of the chair when he won in a democratic way. Lefters couldt stand having lost and tried everything and that is wjhere the Ribaltone comes from. Now too, why dosent Rutelli and his buds let Berlusca stay? If he is so bad, isnt that better for them? so that then in the next elections they will win? Problem is that la sinistra has NO program what so ever and is scared shitless.
No kidding : as I said the absence of a proper plan on behalf of the Left is a main cause of Berlusconi’s rise to power. The fact that he has the means to paint the whole of Italy with posters bearing his effigy and flood his televisions with electoral spots during a campaign (nevermind the “par condicio”, which is supposed to give the same time on the air to each candidate) might also help. Berlusconi is a MASTER at winning electoral campaigns : on that there is not the least doubt. As we can see however he is much less of a master at honouring his promises, and even less so at governing the country.
Quote:
Like what? Your cosa nostra things, I have heard them too many times. its all rumors and NO FACTS. Berlusca is a made man, he started singing in cruises if we want to be right, then I guess had the talent to build and become what he is now. Thing is some people are just against Berlusca for no reason, they dont even listen nor see what he does.
Definition of a populist according to the Oxford Dictionnary : a member of a political party seeking to represent the interests of ordinary people.
As we know, the term now bears a negative connotation, as it designates a politician playing on the people’s instincts to gain sympathy. A populist basically says what people want to hear, no matter how unrealistic it is.
Prime example of Berlusconi’s populism : “I will create one million new jobs !” – 1994. Number of jobs created after his first 7 months in office : - (as in minus) 400. 000.
The mafia accusations. Fact numero 1 : Vittorio Mangano was Cosa Nostra’s man of honour in Milan. Fact nr 2 : he was into drug-trafficking and abductions. Fact nr 3 : Berlusconi hired Vittorio Mangano. Although he was supposed to work in the stables, Mangano would usually spend the day walking 6 neapolitan mastiffs in the Residence’s park. Fact nr 4 : Mangano planned (and failed) the abduction of a guest at a reception held in Berlusca’s mansion, forcing the latter to fire him. Fact number 5 : Dell’Utri – i.e. Berlusca’s closest associate with Previti and Confalonieri – is being prosecuted for this story. And here is the only declaration that Berlusconi deemed necessary to make regarding this issue : “I needed someone who could take care of my horses. I chose Mangano personally, out of a list of names that was presented to me. He made a good impression on me.” I don’t even want to know what other names were on that list for the Cavaliere to decide that Mangano’s was the one who gave him a good impression.
Now I have no idea why you brought up the fact that Berlusconi started his career as a “crooner” on the Riviera Ligure. That’s usually something people would deride him for, except of course his poodle Emilio Fede who sees it as a romantic episode of the Berlusconi saga. “The crooner who became a billionaire” – I reckon we could write a fairy tale on that theme, lol. We could call it “Una storia italiana” and send one free copy with plenty of pictures of the smiling crooner in it to every Italian family just before the next election…oh but wait : Berlusconi already did that!