If only this was a video game career mode in FIFA or FM...
OUT:
Buffon - No renewal, hopefully retires.
Chiellini - No renewal, hopefully retires.
Bonucci - Release.
Alex Sandro - Sell for whatever he worth. Probably peanuts.
Frabotta - Send back to U23 or loan out to Serie B.
Ramsey - Sell for whatever he worth. Midtable EPL teams are probably interested.
Bernardeschi - Sell.
Kulusevski - Sell. No loan out. He's never going to be anything near Juve starter material.
Morata - Love him but he's nearing 30 soon. Not worth spending 55m or so just to witness his downfall.
Dybala - Love him but it all depends on his wage demands, anything more that 9-10m a season is a NO. He's becoming injury-prone at the stage where he should be reaching his peak. We could get a decent fee and free up his wages.
Ronaldo - He's our best player but he's in visible decline. Free up 30m a year in wages and possibly get some fee back. On pitch, he's not worth the 30m a year, maybe off pitch with the marketing.
KEEP:
Szczesny - He saved our asses so many times and he's one of the top GKs in Europe. Probably not in the top 5 but good enough to not waste money on high fees and wages for a new GK.
De Ligt - The future of our defence and possibly the next leader. Flawless.
Demiral - Still makes the odd mistake here and there but he has a potential to work on these tendencies and become great partner for De Ligt.
Danilo - His versatility is key. Has been a great player for us.
Cuadrado - Obviously deserve to stay for a season or two max.
Arthur - The quality is evident, he's 24 and with better midfield partners he could become very important in the near future.
McKennie - Whenever he's fit, he looked very good. Has time to improve further. Doesn't earn much to be considered a burden.
Rabiot - I've seen more positives from Adrien than negatives and he could be a useful player for squad rotation. But if we receive a really good offer for him, we should consider it.
Bentancur - I still believe in him. His qualities are undeniable, needs to work on his mental toughness and similar to Rabiot is a useful player in the squad rotation. He doesn't cost us much in terms of wages, so we have the luxury to give him more time.
Chiesa - Go to Church. Let him be the star man.
Buffon - I don't mind him staying as backup on low wage. Where is the harm in that? He is still better than most back up keepers we could get.
Chiellini - Still good when he is fit, but that is almost never. We shouldn't renew.
Bonucci - He has declined but he's nowhere near as bad as people make him out to be. Still miles better than that fraud Demiral. Besides, nobody would buy him, so he has to stay.
Sandro - He is 30 and in bad form for a while. Still, I wouldn't let him go for nothing considering how hard it is to find a good fullback.
Frabotta - Send him away. He doesn't seem to be a real player.
Ramsey - I am sure a better manager can get a lot more out of him. The problems are his high wage, his age and his wage. His future should depend on how we reinforce the midfield. I doubt many clubs would be interested in him even for free.
Bernardeschi - He had a string of decent games. Hopefully he keeps it up so that he fools some poor suckers into buying him next summer.
Kulusevski - Hard to judge. He had some good moments, but most of the time he has been awful. I can't really judge until I see him playing under a real manager. Btw, I still don't know his position.
Morata - Renew the loan and decide at the end of next season.
Dybala - He was our best player last season but now this fitness issue is worrying. He is also hard to fit in some systems. I love him, he's a great player but maybe we should cash in on him if we can get a good offer.
Ronaldo - Get rid of him while he can still walk and some clubs are still interested for marketinf purposes. His earns as much as 10 players.
Szceszny - Fucked up yesterday but that doesn't mean he has to go. I'd keep him and focus on the real problems.
De Ligt - Keep, obviously.
Demiral - Let's hope that the clubs that fit his level, midtable Turkish league, can afford his salary.
Danilo - Expensive and not very young but he has been one of our most solid players. We can't afford to lose him atm.
Cuadrado - One of our most important players for a few years. The only problem is his age but we should still use him while he performs. Also not a rb.
Arthur - I'm not a huge fan but he obviously needs to stay.
McKennie - I am very skeptical he'll ever develop into anything. Still, we should probably keep him as backup since he is young and has a low wage. We can't change everybody.
Rabiot - He's still young so hopefully we can find some other idiots willing to pay his insane wage. We need to get rid of him asap.
Bentancur - As bad as he has been all season, he was still better than Rabiot, Ramsey, McKennie and Kulusevski. I still have hope that a real manager can get him back on track.
Chiesa - Staying, obviously.