Haven't read through the thread yet, but I assume pretty much everything has already been said. So let's keep it short.
Chimenti 5,5 - Didn't look secure, not at all. But what can you expect from your 3rd goalie?
Grygera 2 - Best not to go into any details about his performance.
Legrottaglie 6,5 - Another competent outing. I hope he was only taken off as a precaution, because otherwise we're even more screwed.
Cannavaro 7 - Good game. Had to cover left, right & center.
De Ceglie 5,5 - Not too much difficulties, but didn't get involved enough.
Marchisio 6,5 - Another competent outing. I hope he was only taken off as a precaution, because otherwise we're even more screwed.
Melo 5 - Mediocre at best. And how many times are we going to allow him to "fight" with the fans?
Sissoko 6 - Really good 1st half, difficulties in the 2nd.
Candreva 6,5 - Excellent 1st half, rather bad 2nd. This guy does seem to have the tendency to completely disappear later on in games.
Del Piero 6,5 - Vital but selfish.
Trezeguet 6 - All right. Did what was asked of him, too bad he was never set up with a decent chance.
Camoranesi 6 - We definitely gain a lot of flair when he's on the pitch. We also lose a lot of workrate.
Salihamidzic 5 - His first minutes looked promising but that's it. Could & should have done a lot better in terms of defending.
Diego -