I'll challenge you to find that/those post(s).
What I have said (repeatedly maybe, not quite sure, old age & all) is that the ratings of the so called experts are often entirely different from what I read on here. Don't know how that relates to either of them being more reliable. Not that I care, I'll judge based on what I see & how I see it.
For me, Vidal was good last night, just like the entire team (bar Vuci), but not exceptional. Players who I thought were more than just good are Pirlo, DP & Pepe.