Fifa are better for Cuadrado, Mandzukic and Buffon, latter two have some resemblance, if slight constipated ones. While PES Cuadrado looks weird, like a little imp. Very far off.
Rest PES look better imo, or closer. Fifa mishit completely with Dybala, Higuain , Pjanic (all 3 barely recognizeable) and tiny bit weirdness in others like Sandro etc (why is Khedira having the haircut he had early 2016 lol).