It's really hard to choose only 11, but here's my list. I put only players that I really watched, that's why there are no players from the 60's-70's-80's. In the spirit of the 90's, my formation is 4-4-2 diamond:
-------------Gigi-----------------
---Cafu---Canna---Nesta---Maldini
------------Davids---------------
--Beckham----------------Nedved
-------------Zidane--------------
--------Ale----------Ronaldo (original)