I'll have a think about this in a more serious manner, in a rough kind of order:
1) Del Piero
2) Scirea
3) Buffon
4) Platini
5) Boniperti
6) Sivori
7) Zoff
8) Tardelli
9) Gentile
10) Baggio
11) Cabrini
12) Nedved
13) Cesarini
14) Orsi
15) Charles
16) Hansen
17) Monti
18) Causio
19) Trezeguet
20) Zidane
21) Davids
22) Combi
23) Rava
24) Salvadore
25) Anastasi
26) Bettega
27) Cuccureddu
28) Furino
29) Brio
30) Chiellini
Maybe in the 30-40 category, along with some more modern players and storied team players from yesteryear/legends from early years.