Paulo Dybala (101 Viewers)

Legend or Rookie? ***non-official poll***


  • Total voters
    140
  • Poll closed .

Adrian

Senior Member
Jan 31, 2003
6,872
Pointless comparing the two and what they earn.

Back to dybala, if he continues to miss an adequate number of games for the remaining season, what does this mean for him and the offers he may receive if this contract extension no longer exists?

Being free will obviously give him leverage to request a higher salary but will teams like inter be willing to pay him 10m per season if he proves he can't stay healthy? In addition, is juve trying to call his bluff thinking that other teams won't match it based on him missing so much football on a consistent basis?

It's not the norm to retract an offer now...so what has happened behind the scenes? What does the club know now that they didn't 3 months ago?
 

Buy on AliExpress.com

Post Ironic

Senior Member
Feb 9, 2013
42,253
Does it really matters what Salah is asking?

Salah is 10 times better than Dybala, he is world class, Dybala isn't, and never will be.

Lpool are rich club , Juve isn't.

The only bad thing managment did, was not selling him last year.

This guy peaked in 2017, pls don't ever compare him to world class players like Salah.

And BTW Chiesa >>>> Dybala

Sent from my SM-G955F using Tapatalk
Dybala was world class from 2015-16 to first half of 2017-18 season. 100%. He was also close to it in 2019-20 with Sarri. And he’s been it so far this season with us. Has been our best player so far this season when fit. I think Chiesa > Dybala too, but Chiesa was both unfit and out of form for much of the first half of this season before his ACL year. Dybala meanwhile has had a great year thus far.
 

Karim30

Allegri is back, life is back.
May 6, 2012
3,610
Does it really matters what Salah is asking?

Salah is 10 times better than Dybala, he is world class, Dybala isn't, and never will be.

Lpool are rich club , Juve isn't.

The only bad thing managment did, was not selling him last year.

This guy peaked in 2017, pls don't ever compare him to world class players like Salah.

And BTW Chiesa >>>> Dybala

Sent from my SM-G955F using Tapatalk
Yeah, read the posts and you’ll understand the context. Salah is better of course that’s why he is asking for almost double the salary.
I sure hope that Chiesa>Dybala I support Juve not the players. Chiesa was better last season for sure, and we can judge by the end of their careers with us.
 

Post Ironic

Senior Member
Feb 9, 2013
42,253
Pointless comparing the two and what they earn.

Back to dybala, if he continues to miss an adequate number of games for the remaining season, what does this mean for him and the offers he may receive if this contract extension no longer exists?

Being free will obviously give him leverage to request a higher salary but will teams like inter be willing to pay him 10m per season if he proves he can't stay healthy? In addition, is juve trying to call his bluff thinking that other teams won't match it based on him missing so much football on a consistent basis?

It's not the norm to retract an offer now...so what has happened behind the scenes? What does the club know now that they didn't 3 months ago?
Needs to stay fit and perform right through the end of this season hopefully leading us to top 4 spot and past Villarreal to CL QFs, both things he’s perfectly capable of doing when fit and in form. If he does this, he’ll have earned his contract and a raise to 8+2 bonus. If he doesn’t stay fit or has trouble with his form again, probably best to let him go.
 

Karim30

Allegri is back, life is back.
May 6, 2012
3,610
Needs to stay fit and perform right through the end of this season hopefully leading us to top 4 spot and past Villarreal to CL QFs, both things he’s perfectly capable of doing when fit and in form. If he does this, he’ll have earned his contract and a raise to 8+2 bonus. If he doesn’t stay fit or has trouble with his form again, probably best to let him go.
Fair enough. Up until now he’s earning his extension.
 

Adrian

Senior Member
Jan 31, 2003
6,872
Not sure why salah is compared to dybala, even chiesa for that matter. They are different players.

You can't criticise dybala for his performances this season, only his ability to stay fit is in question.

- - - Updated - - -

Fair enough. Up until now he’s earning his extension.
When on the field 100 percent. But that isn't the problem right?
 

Karim30

Allegri is back, life is back.
May 6, 2012
3,610
Not sure why salah is compared to dybala, even chiesa for that matter. They are different players.

You can't criticise dybala for his performances this season, only his ability to stay fit is in question.

- - - Updated - - -



When on the field 100 percent. But that isn't the problem right?
This season he's fit around 70% of the time. Last season sucked of course but all the seasons before he was fit for 30+ league games, so hopefully last season was the exception and he's getting back to his normal fitness levels, otherwise we are screwed this season.
 

Bianconero81

Ageing Veteran
Jan 26, 2009
40,175
Does it really matters what Salah is asking?

Salah is 10 times better than Dybala, he is world class, Dybala isn't, and never will be.

Lpool are rich club , Juve isn't.

The only bad thing managment did, was not selling him last year.

This guy peaked in 2017, pls don't ever compare him to world class players like Salah.

And BTW Chiesa >>>> Dybala

Sent from my SM-G955F using Tapatalk
Have some more Haterade. I don't think you've had enough.

7KWf9o.gif


- - - Updated - - -

Thank to @Karim30 @Post Ironic @Adrian @il brutto @s4tch for being the voice of reason in this thread. I would like to apologize to anyone else I may have forgotten.

As for the ungrateful haters, you know yourselves. I'd like to extend a warm fuck you to you and encourage you to keep sipping more of that haterade juice as the season progresses.
 
Last edited:

Robee

Senior Member
Jun 21, 2011
7,006
⚠️ The tension between #Dybala and #Juventus arose from the additional request by the agent of the player after the agreement in October. #Antun has raised the stakes by inserting the image rights of the player in the deal.

[#CorSera via @capuanogio]

So you're saying it's not BiniBene changing the agreement? Shocking.
 

Xperd

Allegrophobic Infidel
Jun 1, 2012
34,897
⚠️ The tension between #Dybala and #Juventus arose from the additional request by the agent of the player after the agreement in October. #Antun has raised the stakes by inserting the image rights of the player in the deal.

[#CorSera via @capuanogio]

So you're saying it's not BiniBene changing the agreement? Shocking.
As far as I remember, even United opted against signing him a couple of years ago because of this image rights issue.

Greedy soyboy
 

Nenz

Senior Member
Apr 17, 2008
10,472
The problem is letting him go for free. If he were paid 10M for 5 years that is surely cheaper than losing a 70 - 90M player for free.
We lose him on a bosman, shed his wages and only have another few million back in the budget to show for it. And we lose another leader. He's filled the leadership void this season. He's not making prima donna, half-arsed efforts for weeks at a time.
I just don't see how letting him go won't end up in his being replaced by Scamacca or Martial. It'll mark another watershed moment in the club's regression to something like what Milan were a few seasons ago. Really, we got lucky in 2010/11. Marotta bought a bunch of revelations for peanuts. That kind of miracle revival is very unlikely to happen again. We need to spend on players who show their worth and, come hell or high water, get rid of those leaches infesting the club at the first opportunity.
 

Robee

Senior Member
Jun 21, 2011
7,006
The problem is letting him go for free. If he were paid 10M for 5 years that is surely cheaper than losing a 70 - 90M player for free.
We lose him on a bosman, shed his wages and only have another few million back in the budget to show for it. And we lose another leader. He's filled the leadership void this season. He's not making prima donna, half-arsed efforts for weeks at a time.
I just don't see how letting him go won't end up in his being replaced by Scamacca or Martial. It'll mark another watershed moment in the club's regression to something like what Milan were a few seasons ago. Really, we got lucky in 2010/11. Marotta bought a bunch of revelations for peanuts. That kind of miracle revival is very unlikely to happen again. We need to spend on players who show their worth and, come hell or high water, get rid of those leaches infesting the club at the first opportunity.
100 million over 5 years to be exact.

And an honest question; who would pay 70 to 90 million for him at this point?

But you're absolutely right; possibly losing him for free is the big problem here.
 

Adrian

Senior Member
Jan 31, 2003
6,872
100 million over 5 years to be exact.

And an honest question; who would pay 70 to 90 million for him at this point?

But you're absolutely right; possibly losing him for free is the big problem here.
No club. But losing him for free will be a disaster considering we tried to offload him a couple of summers ago.

100m over 5 years is a lot. But is the difference between the 10m he wants and what we are offering all that much over a 5 year period? What does that equate to over 5 years at gross? 15 to 20m maybe???

Again, something isn't right here...just doesn't make sense.
 

Elvin

Senior Member
Nov 25, 2005
36,923
I don't see any interest for him tbh. Normally when a star player's contract is ending there are a million suitors.
For example, the whole world wants Mbappe, and actual offers have already been made.
 

Robee

Senior Member
Jun 21, 2011
7,006
No club. But losing him for free will be a disaster considering we tried to offload him a couple of summers ago.

100m over 5 years is a lot. But is the difference between the 10m he wants and what we are offering all that much over a 5 year period? What does that equate to over 5 years at gross? 15 to 20m maybe???

Again, something isn't right here...just doesn't make sense.
Exactly what I thought as well, so his market value is not that high.

100 million is his gross salary and we're probably missing some agent fees as well.
 

Valerio.

Senior Member
Jul 5, 2014
5,762
I'm 50/50 on this. I wouldn't be jubilant if he renews, but I wouldn't shed many tears if he left either. It's difficult.

Ultimately I believe juve aren't benefitting out of any outcome. He's a brilliant player but he's injured half the time. Either we keep him on, take the risk and pay him more, or lose a quality player for free.
I agree and said since a lot.
He is a tactical problem for a team that spent bullshit money on wingers (Ronaldo,Bernardeschi,Chiesa,Kulusevski,Douglas Costa and Cuadrado) in recent years.
In fact we tried to sell him swapping him for Lukaku and the only thing that stopped the deal was Dybala ex-agent asking 40m to new teams to use his img rights.

So leaving everything off unless we switch back to 2man attack (3-5-2 , 4-3-1-2 you name it) where he shined (Mandzukic and then Higuain partnership) or he is better off somewherelse, giving we just spent over 100m on 2 wingers like Chiesa and Kulu (don't mind the fact that they play in the same position duh).

But yeah the only profitable way for Juve would be him renewing for his current wages and SELL IT. not trying and failing! but renew and sell.
Even if it's 35-40m.
That's the only way.

Losing him for free?
a total loss for us

Renewing for stupid money and making him unsellable to any other team?
a loss keeping him on huge wages till he retires.


Problem now it's way too late
and even if you renew you dunno if there is any team that in the summer would give us 40m and the asking wages to the player.
 

Bianconero81

Ageing Veteran
Jan 26, 2009
40,175
I don't see any interest for him tbh. Normally when a star player's contract is ending there are a million suitors.
For example, the whole world wants Mbappe, and actual offers have already been made.
Mbappe is 23 years old and probably the hottest commodity in world football along with Haaland.

Just because you don't see the interest, perhaps due to your extreme bias and delusion, doesn't mean it isn't there. Merda Inter, Atletico, Barcelona, Spurs and even the red cunts of manc have exhibited interest.

bfb41683f1fa7dd10645e449fd020478.gif

74702a560a68af7988cf67df77fbda81.gif
 

Elvin

Senior Member
Nov 25, 2005
36,923
Mbappe is 23 years old and probably the hottest commodity in world football along with Haaland.

Just because you don't see the interest, perhaps due to your extreme bias and delusion, doesn't mean it isn't there. Merda Inter, Atletico, Barcelona, Spurs and even the red cunts of manc have exhibited interest.

bfb41683f1fa7dd10645e449fd020478.gif

74702a560a68af7988cf67df77fbda81.gif
sure sure, we'll see what kinda contract he gets and what kinda career he has once he leaves.
 

Mokku

Senior Member
Apr 17, 2019
2,717
People are missing the point here, it isn't like selling Baggio because we had Del Piero waiting, we have nothing if Dybala goes. Our play is so much worse without him and we don't know what Chiesa will be like when he returns. Look at the bigger picture, we're struggling to even get 4th place and people want him gone. Sell him when he has no worth to us anymore.
 

Elvin

Senior Member
Nov 25, 2005
36,923
People are missing the point here, it isn't like selling Baggio because we had Del Piero waiting, we have nothing if Dybala goes. Our play is so much worse without him and we don't know what Chiesa will be like when he returns. Look at the bigger picture, we're struggling to even get 4th place and people want him gone. Sell him when he has no worth to us anymore.
3-year contract with 8 mil wages max or GTFO.

My fear is getting stuck with him more than losing him.
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 92)