Paulo Dybala (161 Viewers)

[K.O.]

Dybala isn't a legend. The word legend gets used too sporatically these days.

While I agree with you that the word legend shouldn't be used to describe a good servant of the club, there are players in Tuz legends section that hasn't given 50% of what Dybala gave to Juve.

Also, Dybala has given more to Juve than some of the names among the 50 stars in the walk of fame.

 

Buy on AliExpress.com

[Juventino[RUS]]

While I agree with you that the word legend shouldn't be used to describe a good servant of the club, there are players in Tuz legends section that hasn't given 50% of what Dybala gave to Juve.

Also, Dybala has given more to Juve than some of the names among the 50 stars in the walk of fame.

Bruh

 

[K.O.]

Bruh

Zbigniew Boniek - Great player overall. Only 3 years at Juve. Became a Juve hater after leaving the club.
Lucidio Sentimenti - Zero trophies in 7 years, average goalkeeper.

 

[radekas]

Boniek is not in the 50 stars hall of fame.

 

[K.O.]

Boniek is not in the 50 stars hall of fame.

Correct. I checked the wrong list.

Still Sentimenti and other players in the official list have contributed less than Dybala.

 

[radekas]

Correct. I checked the wrong list.

Still Sentimenti and other players in the official list have contributed less than Dybala.

Well maybe the management and fans are... sentimental towards Sentimenti.

Badum tss.

 

[K.O.]

Just for the record, I don't think Dybala should be there. Just pointing out that the word 'legend' is thrown way too often for Juve players.

 

[JuveJay]

You're comparing him to a goalkeeper from the 40s? And how would you know he was average? Sentimenti was a trailblazer with his style of goalkeeping, and Gianni Agnelli said he was the best Juve goalkeeper he had seen (if we are looking between the eras of Combi and Buffon).

 

[K.O.]

You're comparing him to a goalkeeper from the 40s? And how would you know he was average? Sentimenti was a trailblazer with his style of goalkeeping, and Gianni Agnelli said he was the best Juve goalkeeper he had seen (if we are looking between the eras of Combi and Buffon).

I compared their contribution to Juve.

Sentimenti won ZERO trophies for Juve in 7 years. Please explain how he contributed more to Juve than Dybala.

In fact there are so many GKs in Juve who aren't among the 50 legends who contributed way more than him.

 

[Juventino[RUS]]

Zbigniew Boniek - Great player overall. Only 3 years at Juve. Became a Juve hater after leaving the club.
Lucidio Sentimenti - Zero trophies in 7 years, average goalkeeper.

So you didn't even do the fact check...

 

[K.O.]

So you didn't even do the fact check...

Just stick to the argument...

 

[Juventino[RUS]]

I compared their contribution to Juve.

Sentimenti won ZERO trophies for Juve in 7 years. Please explain how he contributed more to Juve than Dybala.

In fact there are so many GKs in Juve who aren't among the 50 legends who contributed way more than him.

Just stop, he wasn't chosen out of nowhere, it's not about the titles, he was local legend between Italians

 

[DAiDEViL]

Ah, the legends discussion.

Been looking forward to it

 

[K.O.]

Just stop, he wasn't chosen out of nowhere, it's not about the titles, he was local legend between Italians

Just stop. It's about titles and contributions.

 

[Juventino[RUS]]

Just stop. It's about titles and contributions.

One of the club’s most decorated legends, Lucidio ‘Cochi’ Sentimenti IV, has sadly passed away today at the age of 94.

The former goalkeeper, who played for the Bianconeri between 1942 and 1949, will be forever remembered as a rare goalscoring shotstopper (five penalties in 188 Juventus appearances) and one of the oldest Italian players to ever feature in a World Cup (Brazil 1950).

After hanging up his gloves, he continued to maintain his passion and enthusiasm for the black and white stripes, returning to help coach the club’s academy prospects towards the end of the 1960s.

One of his most recent returns saw him afforded an incredible standing ovation when he took to the field as one of the club’s 50 legends on the magical night of Juventus Stadium’s opening ceremony.

 

[DAiDEViL]

What? If a player plays for us and doesn't win titels, he can't be a legend? Am I reading this right?

 

[radekas]

I compared their contribution to Juve.

Sentimenti won ZERO trophies for Juve in 7 years. Please explain how he contributed more to Juve than Dybala.

In fact there are so many GKs in Juve who aren't among the 50 legends who contributed way more than him.

Now now, let's not go for the trophies count because Simone Padoin is just around the corner waiting for his legend status.

 

[K.O.]

Just for the record, I don't think Dybala should be there. Just pointing out that the word 'legend' is thrown way too often for Juve players.

^^^

 

[radekas]

I personally think he should be in tuz legends section unless he goes to merda in which case we can just delete his thread.

 

[K.O.]

Titles and contributions are an important part of the parameters in choosing a legend in my book. So if you ONLY won trophies and contributed to Juve success doesn't make you a legend straightaway. If you won nothing, then you're out of the conversation altogether.