I've enjoyed reading your posts actually and it's saved me from having to write a bunch. Even with your corrected post it still suggests that there's somehow a violent aspect to scripture that once followed it can lead to extremism so it's better we don't follow that one aspect of it. I disagree, I know my scripture, and it doesn't teach me to be violent. My apartment is meant to be lived in, if I chose to open my window and start sniping people on the streets, my apartment doesn't become violent a place, it just means there's a violent person in that apartment. Simple as that. You can turn anything into something else.
What I'm really trying to say, and you might not agree with this still, is that people can find justification for their acts by selective reading of scripture. That's all I should have been saying from the start. I don't believe in the slightest that the Koran teaches people to be violent, or causes otherwise non-violent people to lead violent lives. Circumstance and environment cause that. What I do believe though, and I believe it with regards to scripture of most major religions, and people in general, is that Islamic scripture can be interpreted in a way that appears to justify their violent acts. Again, the scripture hasn't led them to violence, nor has it taught them that violence is a path to paradise. But it has been used for justification of the acts of people who would of course find other justification for it if they couldn't find it by selectively picking quotes out of context from scripture.
The problem is that there are (what I would say were) very intelligent individuals leading young, disenfranchised and angry people far astray by telling them what they want to hear: that scripture justifies this violence, even demands it.
I've read the Koran several times, and selections of the Hadiths. I spent 3 semesters studying religion in University, though admittedly not specifically focused on Islam, but more so comparative religions. I'm not all that ill-informed with regards to scripture of any of the world's major religions. My original comment was indeed unfortunate, and I am embarrassed by it, I let an article I was reading run away with my opinion before I sat down and rationally thought about it and read rebuttals of it. I apologize for that.
