Messi vs C.Ronaldo (40 Viewers)

Vote

  • Messi

  • C. Ronaldo


Results are only viewable after voting.
Jul 28, 2021
50
Ok, I wasn't sure of your first language or figures so presumed you meant the mean ranking, which is 35 (based on those numbers). Using a median is a bit strange - what if they played nations ranked 15, 24, 25, 150 and 180 in the world, does 25 seem a fair reflection of difficulty? Also, FIFA rankings are pretty garbage at the best of times. On what planet was Austria from 2016 the 10th best team in the world lol?

There are more stronger teams in Europe than there are in South America, but that's obvious with more countries. I'm not sure of the general point you are making but it seems clear that Portugal didn't meet a lot of the stronger nations, other than Croatia and France, which can happen in a tournament (see England in this Euros).

The way I look at it it's a surprise that Argentina and Brazil don't win the Copa America every tournament, or at least most of them, given their size and player pool in comparison to challenging countries like Uruguay, Colombia or Chile. So for Messi to have won one Copa America is not a huge achievement at his age. Yes it's a team sport, but let's not pretend that he hasn't had his fair share of international flops.
But we won. Just in the last 24 years Argentina forgot to play football and this make that when Brazil was bad Chile/Colombia won a little. I just feel that you understimate Uruguay.

Using 1991~2021 timeline

Chile won two with the same team in this crazy thing of a lot Copa Americas (2015 and 2016). It had the best generation of its story. Just not did better in World Cup because IT IS ALMOST IMPOSSIBLE CHILE DEFEAT BRAZIL. It is really strange, but don't matter how good is their team, they almost always are defeat by us. I think two or three of last world cups this happens. There is a joke in Brazil that says "if we are in a crisis, it just play against Chile"

Colombia won one, and had three good generations in the period. No live to the expectations.

Uruguay is a little understimate by europeans. Besides do bad in world cups in last times except 2010, they always have competitive times and are seeing as the third force here. We have more respect to them then times as Spain for instance. They won 2 in this time gap.

Brazil won 5, besides we don't care a lot for this competion. It is not that no one wants win this, but no one will be remember for won. World Cup is all that matter.

Argentina won 3. The thing is they pass a huge long time without win anything.

Usually Copa America is: Brazil and Argentina the always favorites. Uruguay as next force. And probably one other South American in a good moment. Sometimes Colombia, more recently Chile. Peru had a good moment too, besides didn't won anything and Paraguay is always a bad team organized.

Ecuator miss the altitute in general and don't anything and Bolivia/Venezuela the eternal bad teams that if you don't won it is a shame.

Oh, sometimes invited selections are good, as Mexico and USA, but I think never one won.

Argentina and Uruguay have 15 titles, Brazil 9...and after this it is just a lot of countries with 2 or 1. Brazil have less because we didn't played in a good amount of editions (36 against 41/43 of Argentina and Uruguay) and in old times we send team B in some too. But since become a seriously competion, we are the best with 6 against 4 Uruguay and 3 Argentina.
 

rainhard

Senior Member
May 5, 2004
4,365
1629798724429.png


From fbref for entire career comparison, Messi score 474 goals in minutes that represent 467.6 matches, while CR7 get 479 goals with minutes for 546 games
conclusion :
- CR7 get 5 more goals than Messi with 79 more games, so you can decide who is better
- the other interesting fact is that Messi only get 74 attempted penalty kicks , while CR7 get 111 attempted penalty kicks

So this numbers are facts and if people use facts in numbers to measure, manage and decide then we know who is the better one
 

Orgut

Senior Member
Dec 31, 2002
19,317
This is the GOATness debate, not currently-the-best debate.
Ohh if so the debate should be
Messi vs C.Ronaldo vs Crybaby Ronaldo vs Maradona vs Pele

Tough to say who is the reat GOAT but I personally wouldnt put Cristiano in the top 5 list.
I admire others way more than him.
Zidane had an amazing effect on his team.
Platini was incredible.
I heard Cruyff was pretty good.

and yeah I know Zidane said Ronaldo was better than he was but I still think he is wrong.
 

Elvin

Senior Member
Nov 25, 2005
36,923
Ohh if so the debate should be
Messi vs C.Ronaldo vs Crybaby Ronaldo vs Maradona vs Pele

Tough to say who is the reat GOAT but I personally wouldnt put Cristiano in the top 5 list.
I admire others way more than him.
Zidane had an amazing effect on his team.
Platini was incredible.
I heard Cruyff was pretty good.

and yeah I know Zidane said Ronaldo was better than he was but I still think he is wrong.
Wait till Ronaldo retires. This debate will be done and dusted. The old players just have more myth and charisma about them because Ronaldo is too current. My two cents.
 

Fred

Senior Member
Oct 2, 2003
41,113
I don't know about you guys, but I appreciate good football and those two were two if the greatest to ever do it. Who cares if they had a lot of plastic fans, why can't you just appreciate high level football when you see it?
 

Elvin

Senior Member
Nov 25, 2005
36,923
I don't know about you guys, but I appreciate good football and those two were two if the greatest to ever do it. Who cares if they had a lot of plastic fans, why can't you just appreciate high level football when you see it?
True. Toxic fans were always there. I have participated in a lot of Del Piero vs Totti debates myself, but now I appreciate both. It will happen with Ronaldo-Messi fanboys too IMO.

After retirement lifeong rivals become friends because they realize they have more in common: Al Pacino & De Niro, Sly & Arnold.
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 39)