Martin Cáceres (14 Viewers)

[Elvin]

It wasn't in any particular order. They're pretty much same strength IMO.

 

Buy on AliExpress.com

[Wahdan]

Hmm, that would be my list too.

Puyol is the best defender in the history, but only under one condition: If you're playing PES 2009.

 

[Elgerino]

Seriously, I agree that if your going objectively, it's hard to say who's the best. It's debatable. It depends on the characteristic you prefer a CB to have. But, you can't deny that he's near the very top (I'm not talking about the whole football history, obviously). Puyol has a really great workrate for a defender. I like him a lot.

 

[Alen]

5 days ago there was a friendly between Macedonia and Spain. I saw the highlights and the way Pandev was toying with Puyol was......
I can't find full highlights so only the goals:

Fucking up the offside trap, being dribbled with ease etc.
I know, just a friendly match, but i never rated Puyol in the top 5 and i never will. This friendly against Pandev comes handy for my argument

 

[Kosta]

If all our NT games lasted one half ,we would have been World Champions by now. Leading 2-0 at HT , conceding 3 goals in 5 min in the second half.

 

[Martin]

If all our NT games lasted one half ,we would have been World Champions by now. Leading 2-0 at HT , conceding 3 goals in 5 min in the second half.

That would be a nasty trick on the opposition.

- So now we play the second half.
Ref: No, that's it, there is no second half.
- Whaaaaaat?

 

[sateeh]

Top 5 CBs (right now):

1. Puyol
2. Vidic
3. Chiellini
4. Ferdinand
5. Terry

Giorgone is in Top5 for sure.

He could be up there but his multiple clear and apparent mistakes push him out imo. And i would put Carvalho (spelling?) there.

 

[JuveJay]

Del Piero played in goals as a kid.

And Buffon up front until his mid teens!

 

[Elgerino]

5 days ago there was a friendly between Macedonia and Spain. I saw the highlights and the way Pandev was toying with Puyol was......
I can't find full highlights so only the goals:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z9tDfiAbf0U

Fucking up the offside trap, being dribbled with ease etc.
I know, just a friendly match, but i never rated Puyol in the top 5 and i never will. This friendly against Pandev comes handy for my argument

haha I agree that it was really weak. But are you gonna rate Chiellini differently because of that one match against Chievo (That wasn't even a friendly) ? No, because you know the guy's class on his days. BTW, I'm curious to know who you consider to be in the very top 5 in these days.

 

[Salvatore]

Top 5 CBs (right now):

1. Puyol
2. Vidic
3. Chiellini
4. Ferdinand
5. Terry

Giorgone is in Top5 for sure.

Replace 4 and 5 with Piqué/Pepe and Carvalho. Terry/Ferdinand would probably come directly after those.

 

[Cheesio]

Replace 4 and 5 with Piqué/Pepe and Carvalho. Terry/Ferdinand would probably come directly after those.

what ??
piqué /pepe better than ferdinand and jhon terry ???

 

[Ken]

Replace 4 and 5 with Piqué/Pepe and Carvalho. Terry/Ferdinand would probably come directly after those.

Surely you are taking the piss?

 

[Salvatore]

Harsh on Ferdinand perhaps (recently saw the England-Holland match) but I do think Pepe is a brilliant defender, like Carvalho is. Prefer them both to Terry. Piqué easily has a case as well for top 5 (definitely going to be one of the top of the decade with the way he is progressing).

 

[Sad Statue]

Terry is definately the best for me. A true leader. Ferdinant is good but has been better in the past. Vidic is one of the best. Pepe is not in the list, nor Carvalho. Puyol is very good too and always was a leader for Barca. Pique has been fantastic last year, but just one good year does not put you in the top-5. In addition to that i rate Jamie Carragher very high. He is a very good defender and so many years he is fighting with not so good defenders around him. He is their Chiellini. If i could make a top 6 instead of a top 5, i could put him there...

According to me the top 6 is:

1 - Terry
2 - Vidic
3 - Chiellini
4 - Puyol
5 - Ferdinand
6 - Carragher

 

[The Curr]

1 - Vidic
2 - Chiellini
3 - Pique
4 - Carvalho
5 - Terry

 

[Sad Statue]

The correct top 5 is:

1 - Chiellini
2 - Cannavaro
3 - Caceres
4 - Legrottallie
5 - Ariaudo

 

[The Curr]

The correct top 5 is:

1 - Chiellini
2 - Legrottaglie
3 - Cannavaro
4 - Caceres
5 - Ariaudo

 

[Sad Statue]

i want to hope that caceres will be the pleasant surprise of this season...

 

[Stevie]

The correct top 5 is:

1 - Chiellini
2 - Cannavaro
3 - Caceres
4 - Legrottallie
5 - Ariaudo

What are you serious! where is Molinaro! :evil:

 

[Sad Statue]

What are you serious! where is Molinaro! :evil:

he is not a centre back. thats the only reason he is not there...