Mafia dutch style (2 Viewers)
- Thread starter Bezzy
- Start date
I sucked this game btw, plus was bored with lack of activity when I could be there (that 5 Cs one night thing killed the game IMO) /busy working/sleeping while just occasionally playing with my cell. Most fun games for me are allways when I have time off to completely go through the thread, go in depth/be engaging active paranoid peeps nonstop and only play through my PC (only time in this game I check through comfortably in my PC is tonight, when I'm jailed/its over). Thats why 2 out of my 3 main suspects were Cs and one of them the D lol (though I have super big issue reading Fred for past 2 years in mafia games, allways confuse him for G when he is C, he kinda switched his M.O from what I used to know).
Though completely not suprised Sheik and Kate are Gs (Fresh less, was giving him the benifite of doubt, except for today he became obvious early on). But its the curse of becoming paranoid on the active posters and reading too much into things the more they are posted. Sheik seemed G more and more (mainly Hoori reactions, even for his erratic style that was a little red flag) but more of put on back burner, and kate is allways quiet and not someone that you engage very much, more like short list for later. The mistake you do as a C is allways try to just hunt for the ring leaders, and the more actively influencing players, hence why I got stuck on you, piotrr and Fred in my laziness. Though more actively in general maybe would have made the more quiet Gs stand out bit more suspiciously, but when most of the game is just couple of peeps actively engaging eacother, your narrow tend to become narrow. Less fun when the more games we play, the less engaging/active it turns out to be as a general rule.
And the most fun games for me are ages ago (before the boring routine of inactive games coupled with whacked early etc), before lots of some of the current players didnt use to play (besides Fred, hoori, alen, sheik, and I think Kyle), and majority of the players used to be more excited and active.
And this shit is old, but this is here where I played 90% of my mafia games (better games because half of the manipulation/mind games were through msn chats) lol
http://www.xtratime.org/forum/showthread.php?t=269078
Though completely not suprised Sheik and Kate are Gs (Fresh less, was giving him the benifite of doubt, except for today he became obvious early on). But its the curse of becoming paranoid on the active posters and reading too much into things the more they are posted. Sheik seemed G more and more (mainly Hoori reactions, even for his erratic style that was a little red flag) but more of put on back burner, and kate is allways quiet and not someone that you engage very much, more like short list for later. The mistake you do as a C is allways try to just hunt for the ring leaders, and the more actively influencing players, hence why I got stuck on you, piotrr and Fred in my laziness. Though more actively in general maybe would have made the more quiet Gs stand out bit more suspiciously, but when most of the game is just couple of peeps actively engaging eacother, your narrow tend to become narrow. Less fun when the more games we play, the less engaging/active it turns out to be as a general rule.
And the most fun games for me are ages ago (before the boring routine of inactive games coupled with whacked early etc), before lots of some of the current players didnt use to play (besides Fred, hoori, alen, sheik, and I think Kyle), and majority of the players used to be more excited and active.
And this shit is old, but this is here where I played 90% of my mafia games (better games because half of the manipulation/mind games were through msn chats) lol
http://www.xtratime.org/forum/showthread.php?t=269078
That's why reading your (Gs) posts after the deadline is so hilarious. 
The last 30 min was crazy. We put the votes in, realized we didn't PM Bezzy the whack target, figured we fucked up, saw Fred getting whacked anyway and Kate being blazed. Such a rush of emotions. :d
If you guys want to play another one i can narrate. I think i can handle it.
We need to update the rules though.
We need to update the rules though.
Just my two cents... people really need to stop over thinking people's behaviour (in their posts) and focus more on their actions and the results of them. Some of us think too highly of our ability to read people and would do a lot better to judge on what actually happens as a result of the players' votes rather than what seems to be their intentions 
Just think of how many times you've been wrong when you think someone is being "suss" or weird
Just think of how many times you've been wrong when you think someone is being "suss" or weird
Just my two cents... people really need to stop over thinking people's behaviour (in their posts) and focus more on their actions and the results of them. Some of us think too highly of our ability to read people and would do a lot better to judge on what actually happens as a result of the players' votes rather than what seems to be their intentions
He was calm and composed which is an excellent trait for a c to have, but it wasnt like him, so the fact kyle was playing well as a c made me think he was a g 
Btw i always think you and hoori are g's.
And ocelot, you fvcker despite fvcking up on day 1 you kept weaseling yourself out of trouble with your sweet talk and analytic posts
Btw i always think you and hoori are g's.
And ocelot, you fvcker despite fvcking up on day 1 you kept weaseling yourself out of trouble with your sweet talk and analytic posts
Yes. But even if it wrong conclusion/outcome, its best if people as MUCH AS POSSIBLE goad, pressure, poke, provoke, annoy, question, and antagonize eachother and accuse eachother. Most importantly force eachother to explain their thoughts. I briefly tried, but when others dont find it suspicious that someone doesnt, and accept votes with no reasoning, then it becomes hard to find something to work with. So you tend to over think and get overly paranoid on the little posts available to you that try to explain their thought process. Something Gs hate for sure, but more experienced players can handle, and it was pretty much just Ocelot doing that consistently out of the Gs. Fr3sh tried initially, then he fell back on the melodramatic and outraged/insulted routine While Kate and Sheik coasted by in the peripherals as much as possible, gently making their presence known (until today, sheik outed himself early), but not saying much.
Now if you had hoard of civilians, who question/stand up for themselves, like Fred or Kyle did, and tomice was doing, then it becomes easier to spot them eventually (process of elimination). But more Cs like Zach in this game, quiet and completely unwilling to work with other Cs, and it becomes a very tough task to go anywhere without repeating the same mistakes in the game as an overall team.
While Kate and Sheik coasted by in the peripherals as much as possible, gently making their presence known (until today, sheik outed himself early), but not saying much. Now if you had hoard of civilians, who question/stand up for themselves, like Fred or Kyle did, and tomice was doing, then it becomes easier to spot them eventually (process of elimination). But more Cs like Zach in this game, quiet and completely unwilling to work with other Cs, and it becomes a very tough task to go anywhere without repeating the same mistakes in the game as an overall team.