They were successful result-wise. But as I wrote in the John Elkann thread, since Deschamps left, we haven't added one player to the team, that would be good enough (all our three youngsters were Deschamps' work, he even wanted us to sign Sissoko, which we eventually did). Therefore, in the last two years, we have been playing with the same team. What we are seeing this year is not a dip in form, not an unsuccessful year, it's just the harvest of what the BOD sowed: our key players are getting older, more injury prone, and let's be honest with ourselves, even less effective, and we have no one to replace them with.
You are obviously right with the 2nd part I highlighted. I do think we have tried to replace them, but many of the new players have disappointed.
