Bianconero_Aus

Beppe Marotta Is My God
May 26, 2009
77,227
I see that we are back to blaming a guy who hasn't had a single thing to do with this club in close to 2 years. 2 years in October, actually.

- - - Updated - - -

And it's really funny that the past 2 years since he has not been here, this club hasn't made it out of the last 16.

Yet, when he was here, we made it to 2 CL finals. That's interesting. Actually, 2 CL finals in three years. After Conte left. The same Conte that 90% of the forum took the side of when he left, blaming it on Marotta.

And yet, here we are now. Back to blaming him. Awesome.
The rot properly set into this club after we needlessly fired him and promoted Tweedledee and Tweedledum to replace him.
 

Buy on AliExpress.com

KB824

Senior Member
Sep 16, 2003
31,699
The rot properly set into this club after we needlessly fired him and promoted Tweedledee and Tweedledum to replace him.

Here is something else to think about. If you were to believe everything you read, then Marotta not only decimated the midfield, it would appear that he did nothing to fix it, or other, pressing needs.

Here are some facts.


Vidal & Tevez were sold in 2015. In 2015, what did we do to bring players in? How about Sandro, Mandzukic, Cuadrado, and a certain player by the name of Paulo Dybala

The next year, when Pogba was sold for a world record fee, he was replaced by Pjanic and Higuain. The same Higuain who had just come off of a 38 goal season the year before.

So, did the midfield take a hit? Of course it did. But were other parts of the team significantly strengthened as well? Absolutely. And let's keep in mind that Juve were not in the same financial position 3-4 years ago that they are now.

- - - Updated - - -

Now, this man made some real errors with a number of his purchases. But we can't keep putting some of the blame on someone who hasn't been around, and has had nothing to do with this team for 2 years.
 
Last edited:

Juliano13

Senior Member
May 6, 2012
5,016
Here is something else to think about. If you were to believe everything you read, then Marotta not only decimated the midfield, it would appear that he did nothing to fix it, or other, pressing needs.

Here are some facts.


Vidal & Tevez were sold in 2015. In 2015, what did we do to bring players in? How about Sandro, Mandzukic, Cuadrado, and a certain player by the name of Paulo Dybala

The next year, when Pogba was sold for a world record fee, he was replaced by Pjanic and Higuain. The same Higuain who had just come off of a 38 goal season the year before.

So, did the midfield take a hit? Of course it did. But were other parts of the team significantly strengthened as well? Absolutely. And let's keep in mind that Juve were not in the same financial position 3-4 years ago that they are now.

- - - Updated - - -

Now, this man made some real errors with a number of his purchases. But we can't keep putting some of the blame on someone who hasn't been around, and has had nothing to do with this team for 2 years.
You got balls man, I give you that.

Arguing that Higuain was a good deal after tonigh of all nights.
 
Mar 10, 2009
8,125
He did destroy our midfield. When you get rid of the likes of Pogba and Vidal and replace them with Khedria and Matuidi you know were in trouble. Our problems were masked by Allegri overachieving in the CL with the horrendous garbage we have in arguabbly the most important position.
 

Hydde

Minimiliano Tristelli
Mar 6, 2003
38,724
He did destroy our midfield. When you get rid of the likes of Pogba and Vidal and replace them with Khedria and Matuidi you know were in trouble. Our problems were masked by Allegri overachieving in the CL with the horrendous garbage we have in arguabbly the most important position.
While iu agree with you.... remember that Allegri asked for Khedira and Matuidi, and those players were his favourites.

So dont blame all on Beppes, because if we are stuck with them, it also has todo with Max.

He played them in every formation, remember that. He loved them-
 

Post Ironic

Senior Member
Feb 9, 2013
41,959
:lol:

Max didn’t ask for Khedira and Matuidi.

And aside from that, Khedira was excellent for us in 15-16 and 16-17. He got old and declined and we never replaced him adequately after that.

- - - Updated - - -

I see that we are back to blaming a guy who hasn't had a single thing to do with this club in close to 2 years. 2 years in October, actually.

- - - Updated - - -

And it's really funny that the past 2 years since he has not been here, this club hasn't made it out of the last 16.

Yet, when he was here, we made it to 2 CL finals. That's interesting. Actually, 2 CL finals in three years. After Conte left. The same Conte that 90% of the forum took the side of when he left, blaming it on Marotta.

And yet, here we are now. Back to blaming him. Awesome.
Agree with this entirely, but we made QFs last year ;)
 

KB824

Senior Member
Sep 16, 2003
31,699
While iu agree with you.... remember that Allegri asked for Khedira and Matuidi, and those players were his favourites.

So dont blame all on Beppes, because if we are stuck with them, it also has todo with Max.

He played them in every formation, remember that. He loved them-
Provide evidence of this, please.

Please provide evidence that Max, who had no say whatsoever in player transfers, SPECIFICALLY asked for these 2.

Go ahead. I'll wait.
 

IlCapitano

Senior Member
Dec 16, 2012
5,614
Quite the opposite really. Many journalists have said he asked for a btb mid who's good on the ball since 16/17 (read: SMS). Fabrizio Romano said we had Isco sealed signed and almost delivered before he got fired last year.

Max likes midfielders that get in the box, attack the spaces. Khedira was good at that, but Matuidi for all his virtues held us back so much offensively. Now he's not even good at the back.
 
Last edited:

DAiDEViL

Senior Member
Feb 21, 2015
62,568
While iu agree with you.... remember that Allegri asked for Khedira and Matuidi, and those players were his favourites.

So dont blame all on Beppes, because if we are stuck with them, it also has todo with Max.

He played them in every formation, remember that. He loved them-
LOL glad to have the broken record back together with all his shitty theories.

Also - he played them because he didn't have anything else, you idiot.
 

Oggy

and the Cockroaches
Dec 27, 2005
7,412
:lol:

Max didn’t ask for Khedira and Matuidi.

And aside from that, Khedira was excellent for us in 15-16 and 16-17. He got old and declined and we never replaced him adequately after that.

- - - Updated - - -



Agree with this entirely, but we made QFs last year ;)
Yeah, what's with Khedira obsession, he was great player for us for quite some time, are we gonna call every older player that due to age and injures declined a failed transfer?

And for me, we made mistake by signing Ronaldo, we really did made a statement with his signing, but he came with too much financial burden which restricted us too much. Now we are at the crossroads where we need to rejuvenate the squad with quality players which won't be easy, especially with nowdays prices.

Maybe we needed to make a leap from Marotta, but the man is at no fault for the current situation and Paratici still have a long road to prove himself.
 
Jun 16, 2020
11,036
Provide evidence of this, please.

Please provide evidence that Max, who had no say whatsoever in player transfers, SPECIFICALLY asked for these 2.

Go ahead. I'll wait.
https://www.google.nl/amp/s/www.gaz...-allegri-manchera-piu-3301696844279_amp.shtml

Here’s a article from the Gazzetta where they talking about some of Max’s favorite players; Matuidi en Khedira.

I mean it’s not secret that Allegri highly respected Khedira and he liked Matuidi aswel. With Matuidi’s transfers there have always been rumors that he’d like to have Matic or N’Zonzi instead of Matuidi. Anyway it’s no shame that he liked a certain kind of players, as all coaches have their own style. The discussion with Adani in Max’s last months where he argued that he used three DM’s in Milan’s win vs Barca became quite famous.

Its fair to say that Khedira, Matuidi etc are far less players then Kroos, Casemiro etc on the other side we don’t have to be blind to the facts that he always liked ‘tactical versatile and defensive strong’ players. He’s more a typical Italian manager who always rate those players.

I also don’t think that there were no discussions with Allegri at all regarding our transfers. He was 5 years with us, won a lot and it’s insane to think that Marotta and Paratici totally ignored him when making new signings.
 

s4tch

Senior Member
Mar 23, 2015
28,595
https://www.google.nl/amp/s/www.gaz...-allegri-manchera-piu-3301696844279_amp.shtml

Here’s a article from the Gazzetta where they talking about some of Max’s favorite players; Matuidi en Khedira.
it has nothing to do with allegri requesting the transfer of these two players.

for the millionth time, it's the club that runs the mercato at italian clubs. conte requested lukaku specifically, there are some similar cases here and there, but generally, it's always the club. do anyone think that allegri himself scouted hernanes or pereyra? :rofl: or sarri picked ramsey? (of course not, allegri was our coach when we announced ramsey)

juve coaches work with whatever they have, period. at least it was our strategy since decades.
 
Jun 16, 2020
11,036
it has nothing to do with allegri requesting the transfer of these two players.

for the millionth time, it's the club that runs the mercato at italian clubs. conte requested lukaku specifically, there are some similar cases here and there, but generally, it's always the club. do anyone think that allegri himself scouted hernanes or pereyra? :rofl: or sarri picked ramsey? (of course not, allegri was our coach when we announced ramsey)

juve coaches work with whatever they have, period. at least it was our strategy since decades.
Yes the directors do the mercato but I highly doubt that there’s no communication at all.

Conte didn’t got Lukaku, but they gave him a lot of other players like Asamoah, Giovinco, Pogba, Ogbonna etc.

Its not fair to say that they totally ignore the managers, especially at Juve where our directors are famous of standing really close to the team.
 

s4tch

Senior Member
Mar 23, 2015
28,595
Yes the directors do the mercato but I highly doubt that there’s no communication at all.

Conte didn’t got Lukaku, but they gave him a lot of other players like Asamoah, Giovinco, Pogba, Ogbonna etc.

Its not fair to say that they totally ignore the managers, especially at Juve where our directors are famous of standing really close to the team.
i meant conte at inda requested and got lukaku, and it's a rare sight.

allegri asked for a trequartista and got hernanes. i bet marotta was standing really close to him. you're right, there's some communication and the club doesn't completely ignore the coach (and i didn't even suggest that)

people often confuse the english manager role with the italian coaching role. in the pl, managers pick the majority of their players, they are actively involved in the mercato. at juve, both moggi and marotta sold whoever they wanted. i bet allegri would have kept vidal and pogba if it was up to him. but it's only a matter of time before some guys start blaming the coaches for selling our assets.
 

campionesidd

Senior Member
Mar 16, 2013
15,465
Here is something else to think about. If you were to believe everything you read, then Marotta not only decimated the midfield, it would appear that he did nothing to fix it, or other, pressing needs.

Here are some facts.


Vidal & Tevez were sold in 2015. In 2015, what did we do to bring players in? How about Sandro, Mandzukic, Cuadrado, and a certain player by the name of Paulo Dybala

The next year, when Pogba was sold for a world record fee, he was replaced by Pjanic and Higuain. The same Higuain who had just come off of a 38 goal season the year before.

So, did the midfield take a hit? Of course it did. But were other parts of the team significantly strengthened as well? Absolutely. And let's keep in mind that Juve were not in the same financial position 3-4 years ago that they are now.

- - - Updated - - -

Now, this man made some real errors with a number of his purchases. But we can't keep putting some of the blame on someone who hasn't been around, and has had nothing to do with this team for 2 years.
We may laugh at his policy to sign cheap players from smaller Italian clubs as backups, but they did play a large part in our early success. Padoin, Caceres, even Sturaro (in his first two seasons) played really well when they were asked to. They did their job, remained fit and did not eat up our wage bill. Contrast that with today's scenario where the likes of Khedira, Higuian, Rugani, Douglas Costa, De Sciglio, Danilo do nothing but earn fat cheques while sitting on the sidelines.
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 6)