Giuseppe Marotta (1,008 Viewers)

[Klin]

I am sure a lot more people would be more inclined to appreciate Marotta if there were more balanced members supporting him (X, Sergio, and to a certain extent Klin; can't believe I am mentioning him )

However, the daily praise and need to defend him @ every opportunity on a daily basis makes it that much easier to dislike the man and vent.

Believe it. I'm the most balanced member on this forum.

Fuck you, @baggio.

 

Buy on AliExpress.com

[MikeM]

I am sure a lot more people would be more inclined to appreciate Marotta if there were more balanced members supporting him (X, Sergio, and to a certain extent Klin; can't believe I am mentioning him )

However, the daily praise and need to defend him @ every opportunity on a daily basis makes it that much easier to dislike the man and vent.

I'm pretty balanced but I just hate the fact that someone could catch so much unwarranted flack for doing his job. Marotta was brought here to revive Juventus. Are we revived? Yes. Did we win titles? Yes. Are win a great position for the future? Yes.

Now everyone shut up. I don't care if he wasted some money here and there. He's not perfect but the job was done in a very satisfactory manner. You're happy and proud to support Juventus again. So what good is it to whine that he paid 18M for Matri when he should have paid 14.23423525M instead? Just shut up already.

If someone put a gun to everyone's head, they'd all decide to keep Marotta, I'm fucking positive of that fact. They just like to critique meaningless things over and over.

 

[Bianconero81]

You are definitely a balanced member, actually one of the most interesting to read and insightful. I am sorry I forgot to mention you

- - - Updated - - -

Believe it. I'm the most balanced member on this forum.

Fuck you, @baggio.

@baggio is awesome, but only when he doesn't go full retard on Quag. His obsession with Quag is almost as disturbing as Sheik's with Giac.

 

[Zacheryah]

"damage"

If Marotta did damage, we would be a seller club like milan.
Or you know, the rest of serie a.

 

[KB824]

I am sure a lot more people would be more inclined to appreciate Marotta if there were more balanced members supporting him (X, Sergio, and to a certain extent Klin; can't believe I am mentioning him )

However, the daily praise and need to defend him @ every opportunity on a daily basis makes it that much easier to dislike the man and vent.

It works both ways. The daily scorn and need to make him out to be Hitler reincarnated is just as aggravating. Like or dislike the man based on his performances, not because certain members have hard-ons pointing in opposite directions.


For those who go overboard in the effusive praise of Beppe, you would think that this club has just won the Champions League or something of that regard. And for those who deride him, you would think that this is a mid-table club in the midst of its 4th consecutive 7th place finish.


The guy is not perfect. No DS is. It just doesn't happen. I certainly don't remember a whole lot of Moggi bashing when some of his costly mistakes in the transfer market (more than some people would want to admit) didn't pan out. Hell, even Secco has had a larger leash than Beppe, and he fucked up royally. The team finished in 7th place in 2009-2010 for a reason. It was an old, an unbalanced team, that was on his watch. But some people cast him in a sympathetic light. Give me a fucking break.

 

[Zacheryah]

You people just take it all so simply.

forget about the ugly truths.

How juve had and serie a has a shit appeal.
How we dont that the money to pay the wages to convince players here despite the appeal.
How we had to restrict to promising, not finished players.

Serie a ? as long as we arent on the level of barcelona, madrid, bayeren and manchester utd, this league has a massive disadvantage

Players could go to athletico, or tottenham, just because they play in a league with one of those teams, they get noticed and could get their dreammove. Serie a ends with juventus, as long as it isnt on their level, its that much less attractive.

So marotta goes for the big potential players, but not to obvious ones, ones that we can actually get. This means italians, who dont leave italy and consider juve as the peak of their carreer. Or a player like vidal.
But it also means the risk of getting krasic, martinez. They could have turned out great, but didnt deliver.

This is the case with most managers. Watch every team richer then us, you'll quickly see massive loads of cash invested into players that didnt deliver it.

However, Marotta has been SO very costefficient. He lost transfer cash, but didnt overdo the wages, so its not that big deal. as an offset, he kept a tight wage structure, as a further improvement. Lastly, the players marotta got that delivered, increased so much in marketvalue, that if we'd sell them today, we would be having 3 times the money we lost on fee and wages of the unsuccesfull players. This is what makes marotta such succesfull manager

 

[Quetzalcoatl]

He has faults, and he was strengths. We're succeeding sports-wise and financially, improving year by year on both fronts. As long as this is happening, he can sign all the Lodis and Boneras, and miss out on all the Agueros and Higuains he wants.

 

[KB824]

I have a question that I would like to pose everyone, and take as much time as you need.

In 12 years as the transfer director, how many champions or top level players did Moggi buy? Please be objective. I understand that is a foreign concept for some, but at least try. Thank you

 

[Klovn]

I wouldn't call llorente a successful one yet too, in fact it's a pretty meh transfer so far

 

[Lion]

I have a question that I would like to pose everyone, and take as much time as you need.

In 12 years as the transfer director, how many champions or top level players did Moggi buy? Please be objective. I understand that is a foreign concept for some, but at least try. Thank you

forget about the buying part.

juventus is bullied around when it cmes to selling. it's funny to see memebers and marotta complain about the economic situtation on the league, yet we act like man city having reserve players that earn millions and contribute nothing.

the melo fiasco is insane.
motta
martinez
ziegler


shameful. in no other big club do you see the same problem

 

[Völler]

I have a question that I would like to pose everyone, and take as much time as you need.

In 12 years as the transfer director, how many champions or top level players did Moggi buy? Please be objective. I understand that is a foreign concept for some, but at least try. Thank you

What kind of bullshit is this. Your are asking a question that almost couldn't be more subjective. A good transfer is not exclusively based on numbers and facts, but on personal opinions and how well you think a player performed. Furthermore, are you actually expecting anyone to go through 12 years of transfer history just to give you the number of top level players Moggi bought? I didn't think so either, but if you think your question is so interesting, then it might be a good idea to provide a link to such a list.

 

[Zacheryah]

forget about the buying part.

juventus is bullied around when it cmes to selling. it's funny to see memebers and marotta complain about the economic situtation on the league, yet we act like man city having reserve players that earn millions and contribute nothing.

the melo fiasco is insane.
motta
martinez
ziegler


shameful. in no other big club do you see the same problem

Try selling players witout appeal.

Ziegler ? joined us for free

Motta ? horrible failed and to high wages

Martinez ? allways injured, if he wasent, very bad games. also didnt want to leave

Melo ? we had to get a loan out to fucking turkey to get rid of him. thats how no one wanted it

 

[Lion]

no excuses.

it's his job to sell. every other club does it.....and without the fuss

 

[Bianconero_Aus]

forget about the buying part.

juventus is bullied around when it cmes to selling. it's funny to see memebers and marotta complain about the economic situtation on the league, yet we act like man city having reserve players that earn millions and contribute nothing.

the melo fiasco is insane.
motta
martinez
ziegler


shameful. in no other big club do you see the same problem

Thank Secco for the Felipe Melo situation. Martinez was a royal fuck up by Marotta, not sure why the hell he decided to spend 12M on that guy when he could barely run properly. I know he was good at Catania, but it was still an extremely odd transfer and easily his biggest disaster.

Motta and Ziegler will eventually be sold to some shit teams for a few mill. I hardly think there is much of a problem with them two.

 

[Suns]

I've become a Marotta fan and totally changed my view on him but day by day I'm realizing that Conte makes him look really good. Conte has overachieved greatly with a few player that really have no business in performing this well.

 

[Lion]

there are no excuses here. it's his job to sell them and he failed. i can undertand one or two players. but that many is too high a number and it indicates a big probelm. this isnt some random issue.

i guarantee we will have the same problem if we try to sell giach/vuci/gio/matri/quag

 

[Zacheryah]

there are no excuses here. it's his job to sell them and he failed. i can undertand one or two players. but that many is too high a number and it indicates a big probelm. this isnt some random issue.

i guarantee we will have the same problem if we try to sell giach/vuci/gio/matri/quag

I've become a Marotta fan and totally changed my view on him but day by day I'm realizing that Conte makes him look really good. Conte has overachieved greatly with a few player that really have no business in performing this well.

Overachieved ?

Conte got the best out of his players, wich is the job of any good coach.

Conte is just unleashing the potential that beppe sees in them. thats why they are such a fantastic duo.

Beppe first sign a number of cheap players that perfoms good under conte, in a addition to a few players that now carry the team.

barzagli, bonucci,lichtsteiner,caceres,vidal,asamoah,vucinic. they arent overachieving, they are just that good

 

[Bianconero_Aus]

What makes you think we want to sell all those players anyway? Do people expect us to play with a squad of 11 players?

Pretty sure Giovinco and Matri are staying no matter what. Most likely Vucinic as well. All players who contributed to two Scudetti.

 

[KB824]

What kind of bullshit is this. Your are asking a question that almost couldn't be more subjective. A good transfer is not exclusively based on numbers and facts, but on personal opinions and how well you think a player performed. Furthermore, are you actually expecting anyone to go through 12 years of transfer history just to give you the number of top level players Moggi bought? I didn't think so either, but if you think your question is so interesting, then it might be a good idea to provide a link to such a list.

You're a Juve fan. I'm pretty sure that you can come up with a list of your personal preferences. There is a reason why I am asking this.

 

[Bianconero_Aus]

I've become a Marotta fan and totally changed my view on him but day by day I'm realizing that Conte makes him look really good. Conte has overachieved greatly with a few player that really have no business in performing this well.

Of course Conte gets most of the credit. He is a fantastic coach who has worked wonders with the squad he has been given, but if you seriously dont think that Beppe hasn't assembled the best (by far) team in Italy, then you're vastly underrating our players. He's put together an extremely solid team, whether we had Conte or not, it's still the strongest in the league. Vidal, Lichtsteiner, Barzagli, Bonucci, Pirlo, Pogba, and even Vucinic, would walk into the starting lineup in EVERY team in Italy.