Its incredible to read suggestions of our team not lacking much when Melo is suspended...its as if they have been watching a completely different team to me all this season. He is a lynchpin of all our better, stronger performances. He allows Aquilani to create, by shielding him, and also giving aqui a safe option to pass to and play off. he screens the defence, helps out our right flank allowing krasic to bomb forward...without him, with either marchisio or momo in his place, our midfield is horrible. The connection between defence and attack is almost solely long balls. Gaps appear on the right flank.
Other than that costly red card against parma, he has been our most consistent solid midfielder.
Marchisio lacks both the passing and tackling skills, as well as the physical strength. Momo is perhaps calmer, but also far weaker technically...you see this so clearly when he plays with aqui. We have only ONE player in the middle who can pass, so mark aqui, and completely cut off the supply to our forwards.
Of course we are missing quags also, but melo seems much more important for this team, as our midfield is the only section of defence/offence/midfield which when fit and healthy, often looks like one of the best in the league. take melo out of the midfield, and we look more like brescia...