[EU] Europa League 2014/15 (7 Viewers)

Hist

Founder of Hism
Jan 18, 2009
11,626
1) No one has gotten more stick this season than Sebastian Mignolet. Even Lovren has been called out in the papers, same with Markovic. Balo got his share of "wake the $#@! up" from the manager and with the exception of Lovren, those players have been improved.

2) Gerrard can say what he wants. He's a legend, the captain, the star of the team. Don't break the hierarchy simple as that. If you do, don't be surprised when captain fantastic comes down on you.

3) The english players on the team don't get protection. They haven't needed it this season. Gerrard, Henderson, Sterling, Sturridge, Lallana, Ibe have all been solid. The only guy that's really been protected by the manager is Skrtel.
I havent seen Lallana getting any wake the fuck up or being publicly told to work harder or being given half of the attention that balotelli got. Lallana has been far from solid especially for a mega transfer. I really disagree on everyone getting an equal share of public criticism from Rogers but I wont argue for it because that would involve looking up articles and things I am too lazy to do.


What Gerrard did was wrong there is no two ways around it. You pool fans might take anything from him sure and accept things from him that you wouldnt accept from others sure, but that doesn't make what he did right in anyway. Captain fantastic should come down on him in private not in public it is as simple as that. What Gerrard did is wrong and in most cases if Rogers himself did it then is also wrong.
 

Buy on AliExpress.com

Enron

Tickle Me
Moderator
Oct 11, 2005
75,667
There is no such thing as earning the right to say whatever you want. A captain should motivate his team and take the pressure off of him. As should the coach. Liverpool is doing the opposite of that. Rogers was blaming balotelli for his own failures during the first half of the season while he barely said anything against the greater and more expensive flops like Lovren, Lallana and Markovic who did have a pre-season with the club and weren't last minute panic buys.

Now Gerrard calling out a player who has is now finally performing and who they are in dire need of. Thats classless and stupid.
You won't see Buffon or any other captain with a brain do that. Gerrard is acting like Casillas' wife. If Buffon does something similar, I'd be questioning his wisdom too.

Rogers should 1) give gerrard a talking to 2) force gerrard to publicly apologize to balo and 3) give balo a warning 4)tell the media that there is no problem and that Pool deals with these things behind closed doors.
Rogers called out everyone this season and everyone he called out is playing better. What you're getting at, how Balo has been treated so poorly, just isn't there. Rogers has even called out Borini and Lambert at times. But he's also praised these players when they've done well.

You need to update your news man. Lallana and Markovic have been on fire lately. Both are now starting on a regular basis. Lallana was injured for the first month of the season and Markovic needed time to settle in. Even Emre Can is starting.
 

Hist

Founder of Hism
Jan 18, 2009
11,626
Yes, there is. For a player of his background and his story with the club, definitely there is.

Not when his playmate disrespects everybody, people he's known for ages. Who the hell is Balotelli to overrule the coach's decision?

Maybe he deserved it. Or did you forget how he used to be with Mancini? Balotelli is an uncontrollable child.

And no, i disagree with pretty much everything.
Balo deserves a stern warning if not a punishment I am not disagreeing with that.

But what Gerrard did is also inexcusable. This is no different from Totti refusing to be Subbed or totti ordering off one of the players to be substituted. The fans can forgive such mistakes because Totti is a legend, but that doesn't make this not a mistake.
 

Enron

Tickle Me
Moderator
Oct 11, 2005
75,667
I havent seen Lallana getting any wake the fuck up or being publicly told to work harder or being given half of the attention that balotelli got. Lallana has been far from solid especially for a mega transfer. I really disagree on everyone getting an equal share of public criticism from Rogers but I wont argue for it because that would involve looking up articles and things I am too lazy to do.


What Gerrard did was wrong there is no two ways around it. You pool fans might take anything from him sure and accept things from him that you wouldnt accept from others sure, but that doesn't make what he did right in anyway. Captain fantastic should come down on him in private not in public it is as simple as that. What Gerrard did is wrong and in most cases if Rogers himself did it then is also wrong.
I have no problem agreeing to disagree.:D
 

Hist

Founder of Hism
Jan 18, 2009
11,626
Rogers called out everyone this season and everyone he called out is playing better. What you're getting at, how Balo has been treated so poorly, just isn't there. Rogers has even called out Borini and Lambert at times. But he's also praised these players when they've done well.

You need to update your news man. Lallana and Markovic have been on fire lately. Both are now starting on a regular basis. Lallana was injured for the first month of the season and Markovic needed time to settle in. Even Emre Can is starting.
I follow liverpool too I hardly call that players on fire. They are less on fire than Morata is for us. They are starting regularly because it is a shit squad. Liverpool won't keep their results up for long.
 

Enron

Tickle Me
Moderator
Oct 11, 2005
75,667
I follow liverpool too I hardly call that players on fire. They are less on fire than Morata is for us. They are starting regularly because it is a shit squad. Liverpool won't keep their results up for long.
We'll be alright Mr. Negativity.
 

Hist

Founder of Hism
Jan 18, 2009
11,626
I have no problem agreeing to disagree.:D
I have no problem either but I'd like to know more about your perspective on the Gerrard issue.

Do you think Gerrard publicly (instead of privately) dealing with Balo's situation is:
1) Wrong but excusable a la totti.
2) Not wrong. Balo made a mistake and he called him out. In public or private doesn't make a difference. Only the captain has that right though.
3) Not wrong. balo made a mistake. Any player has the right to publicly out their teammates in a similar situation.

- - - Updated - - -

"Thank you Hendo for let [sic] me take the penalty.. Stop drama now. We won that's what it [sic] count. We are a team and expecially [sic] we are Liverpool. Come on guys." - Balotelli.


He should have said stop acting like Casillas' wife captain.
 

CrimsonianKing

Count Mbangula
Jan 16, 2013
27,333
Balo deserves a stern warning if not a punishment I am not disagreeing with that.

But what Gerrard did is also inexcusable. This is no different from Totti refusing to be Subbed or totti ordering off one of the players to be substituted. The fans can forgive such mistakes because Totti is a legend, but that doesn't make this not a mistake.
Actually, what Balotelli did is no different from that.

Totti is another big child. But at least he's an important figure, if only for Roma.

We'll have to agree to disagree then. I think Gerrard has every right to be against this kind of behavior and talk about it, publicly or not.
 
Jul 20, 2012
20,044
Balo deserves a stern warning if not a punishment I am not disagreeing with that.

But what Gerrard did is also inexcusable. This is no different from Totti refusing to be Subbed or totti ordering off one of the players to be substituted. The fans can forgive such mistakes because Totti is a legend, but that doesn't make this not a mistake.
when was this ? :D
 

Enron

Tickle Me
Moderator
Oct 11, 2005
75,667
I have no problem either but I'd like to know more about your perspective on the Gerrard issue.

Do you think Gerrard publicly (instead of privately) dealing with Balo's situation is:
1) Wrong but excusable a la totti.
2) Not wrong. Balo made a mistake and he called him out. In public or private doesn't make a difference. Only the captain has that right though.
3) Not wrong. balo made a mistake. Any player has the right to publicly out their teammates in a similar situation.

- - - Updated - - -

"Thank you Hendo for let [sic] me take the penalty.. Stop drama now. We won that's what it [sic] count. We are a team and expecially [sic] we are Liverpool. Come on guys." - Balotelli.


He should have said stop acting like Casillas' wife captain.
I don't 100% agree with it. Probably always better to handle things in house, unless it's the manager.
 

Hist

Founder of Hism
Jan 18, 2009
11,626
If I remember correctly it was under Ranieri? Someone with a better memory has to confirm. But yeah it happened. Totti refused to get subbed.

But by Crimsonian King's books, he can do whatever he wants because he is a legend and a star and so has earned the right to screw his own team over if he wants and is beyond punishment for mistakes that he made.

- - - Updated - - -

I don't 100% agree with it. Probably always better to handle things in house, unless it's the manager.
Ok I can understand that.
 

MikeM

Footballing Hipster celebrating 4th place with Tuz
Sep 21, 2008
12,850
If there's one quote that can sum up a player it's "Why so serious?".

Balotelli takes the penalty, scores and then he gives Henderson a hug and thanks him. He has no clue about what he's done. I honestly don't think he knows how serious things like this are. To him it's just a penalty shot and obviously he should take it since his record is like 99%. Henderson lets him take it and he scores. What's the big deal he probably thinks to himself.
 

Enron

Tickle Me
Moderator
Oct 11, 2005
75,667
If there's one quote that can sum up a player it's "Why so serious?".

Balotelli takes the penalty, scores and then he gives Henderson a hug and thanks him. He has no clue about what he's done. I honestly don't think he knows how serious things like this are. To him it's just a penalty shot and obviously he should take it since his record is like 99%. Henderson lets him take it and he scores. What's the big deal he probably thinks to himself.
That's why I said it's just Mario being Mario. I don't think there was any malicious intent and Henderson certainly wasn't greatly offended. However, there was obviously a set instruction as to who was the day's penalty taker. If anything I thought Henderson handled it like champ.
 

CrimsonianKing

Count Mbangula
Jan 16, 2013
27,333
If I remember correctly it was under Ranieri? Someone with a better memory has to confirm. But yeah it happened. Totti refused to get subbed.

But by Crimsonian King's books, he can do whatever he wants because he is a legend and a star and so has earned the right to screw his own team over if he wants and is beyond punishment for mistakes that he made.
:facepalm2: This is what the Messi-Ronaldo generation is used to, players with no personalities, no opinions. Nothing bad can be said about anyone even if it's only being honest and passionate. Modern Football truly sucks, i don't know why i even bother.
 

MikeM

Footballing Hipster celebrating 4th place with Tuz
Sep 21, 2008
12,850
That's why I said it's just Mario being Mario. I don't think there was any malicious intent and Henderson certainly wasn't greatly offended. However, there was obviously a set instruction as to who was the day's penalty taker. If anything I thought Henderson handled it like champ.
Henderson handled it perfectly.
 

CrimsonianKing

Count Mbangula
Jan 16, 2013
27,333
If there's one quote that can sum up a player it's "Why so serious?".

Balotelli takes the penalty, scores and then he gives Henderson a hug and thanks him. He has no clue about what he's done. I honestly don't think he knows how serious things like this are. To him it's just a penalty shot and obviously he should take it since his record is like 99%. Henderson lets him take it and he scores. What's the big deal he probably thinks to himself.
He's a big child indeed. I don't think there's malice from him but he's seriously in the wrong profession when he was so infantile and stubborn.

That's why I said it's just Mario being Mario. I don't think there was any malicious intent and Henderson certainly wasn't greatly offended. However, there was obviously a set instruction as to who was the day's penalty taker. If anything I thought Henderson handled it like champ.
He did. Although I'm not sure i'd the same, I'm with Gerrard that he should have stood his ground. If he's to be the captain when Gerrard leaves then he simply can't allow to be treated like that. He's gotta earn his respect.
 

MikeM

Footballing Hipster celebrating 4th place with Tuz
Sep 21, 2008
12,850
He's a big child indeed. I don't think there's malice from him but he's seriously in the wrong profession when he was so infantile and stubborn.



He did. Although I'm not sure i'd the same, I'm with Gerrard that he should have stood his ground. If he's to be the captain when Gerrard leaves then he simply can't allow to be treated like that. He's gotta earn his respect.
I think Henderson earns more respect by the way he handled it then by fighting Balotelli.
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 7)