Again, some of you are again and again forgetting that Claudio is playing out of his position since the start of the season because our management failed to find a decent LM player instead they got us Martinez who can't walk properly let alone sprinting and running.
Marchisio should be playing in his neutral position had we had someone better than Martinez. Aquilani is doing better than Marchi.
natural - it's the second time you call it neutral
While what you say has logic, I think it's not true for this particular case, or at least it's not the decisive factor in Marchisio's performances. Just like in the previous two seasons, when he played in his natural position, Claudio this year had some 4-5 brilliant matches, some good matches where he did what was asked from him and performed a strictly tactical role, but he also had a good number of matches where tactics weren't the reason why he played bad and looked indifferent to what is happening on the pitch.
His numbers are good this year. Better than the previous seasons. With 4 goals, 4 assists and 1 goal that was his but counted as an owngoal for Genoa's keeper he's our top performing midfielder after Milos, with much better numbers than his partners in midfield Melo and Aquilani. No matter if he played CM, LM or was one of the trio midfielders (when we played 4-3-3), his performances in all these positions are same/similar. In all these positions he had great/good/average/bad matches.
I know that the way this team plays (too inconsistent) reflects on how the individuals play. Krasic, Del Piero, Melo, Chiellini all had good and bad matches, just like Claudio. But unlike the mentioned above, who played bad when the entire team played bad, with Marchisio it's a little different because even when the team played well, he knows to be invisible and useless. In the previous years his youth and inexperience were excusing such attitude. Now he's 25 and he must make the step in quality and consistency. He must take more responsibility and even lead the team instead of simply disappearing and playing a good match once a month.
He has the quality to do it. I believe there is truth in the rumors that United or other big teams following him. They're doing that because they can see the potential and quality. Now it's up to him to become a regular top performer because if he doesn't and he offers us good matches once a month, then 20m eur or close to it makes it too attractive to refuse if someone offers us such money for him.