Hist, I like your perspective

int:
- - - Updated - - -
all of this beautiful narrative is based on 2 humongous assumptions: you will be able to make enough money, and out of your recruits some will blossom into very good players. This strategy, in my mind, will never turn you into a sustainable top team. To be a real top team you have to spend, no 2 ways about it.
If only we could go the route of recruiting one top player a year, we could easily phase out, pirlo, barzagli and buffon in that order. Instead, we will most liekly turn into post treble inter.
I partially agree. You are spot on when you say that the young replacements that should supposedly become the backbone have to really blossom if that strategy is going to work. Thats why I think we were after Iturbe and Morata rather than complete unknowns. While they are more expensive they arent exactly pure potential like Koman. But ofcoarse they can deteriorate like Diego did before.
I disagree however about the post-treble Inter part. I dont think you can phase out Pirlo, Barzagli,Buffon, Vidal and Pogba. The old guys are really really old and every one of them is simply too important for the team and irreplaceable. You'll need 3 World class players to phase out Pirlo,Barza and Buffon and all have to be replaced within two years. That would cost around a 100 mill in spending to only keep the team at the same footballing level it is at now! (dont forget that licht, chiellini and marchisio arent exactly youngsters either)
That is not mentioning that it will be incredibly difficult to keep both Vidal and Pogba from Madrid and Co. In other words we currently have three world class veterans that'll need a 100 mill to replace and two younger players that are too good and have been around for too long to be talked into staying beyond 2 seasons(pogs especially)... All 5 of them absolutely key players in the current structure and will almost certainly be gone in one or two years max.
If anything the Conte road is more dangerous. While we might win the CL (though thats far from a certainty) if we had bought one or two expensive world class players, we'd possibly become the post treble Inter. Inter had a squad that had peaked and added world class players in Eto, Milito, Sneijder, and Lucio but then suddenly had the team's core incredibly decline. It didnt help that the world class acquisitions were all close to or in their thirties either. Imagine us buying 2 world class 27 years olds and then have the the aforementioned 5 gone at once.
The ideal scenario for Juve was to restructure the team's core under a competent coach who knows the surroundings and knows every strength and weakness in the squad like Conte. this can maintain the team's level but that would entail a repeat of the last few seasons. Conte's reputation has suffered massively last season and there is no way anyone can rightfully attack him for not wanting more of the same.
You cant ask him to rebuild and maintain the next 2-3 years and then start proving people wrong about how good of a coach you are.