Should be based on foot position alone imo. Attackers are often leaning towards goal as they start their runs. Whereas defenders leaning the opposite way as they watch man with ball/move to spring offside trap. Attacking advantage should be just that, body can be leaning past but feet have to be in line, which is very obvious marker for offsides without controversy, and not this nonsense where a player is leaning offside with his shoulder or his knee is bent past by a couple cm.
Same deal with ice hockey, you aren’t offside because you have your stick or your body leaning across the blue line before puck enters. Your skates have to be across.
Attacking player should only have to worry about feet. Clearest and best offside rule possible in my opinion.
@DAiDEViL
Morata would probably still be offside lots, because he clearly plays his game at the margins trying to get every little bit of advantage possible in terms of positioning. Most players who have that style are often offside. It’s annoying, but it’s also part of why he is so effective and constantly draws the attention of defensive line.
Same deal with ice hockey, you aren’t offside because you have your stick or your body leaning across the blue line before puck enters. Your skates have to be across.
Attacking player should only have to worry about feet. Clearest and best offside rule possible in my opinion.
@DAiDEViL
Morata would probably still be offside lots, because he clearly plays his game at the margins trying to get every little bit of advantage possible in terms of positioning. Most players who have that style are often offside. It’s annoying, but it’s also part of why he is so effective and constantly draws the attention of defensive line.
Buy on AliExpress.com
