I know that many might not agree with me on this but I feel Aquilani is overated and would get Xabi over him anyday. I feel its the romantic idea of having him as the new best midfield thing in Italian football that makes him overrated.
I feel its the same way people wanted to see the next DP in Palladino but it just wouldnt happen. I know its arguable that he hasnt been given enough time to shine but at 24 turning 25, other very good players of similar age (or younger) have blown people away enough to command starting places in their teams