X Mas is arrived at Lovtuz part 3 (3 Viewers)
- Thread starter Bezzy
- Start date
Cheese just won the worst mafia player of all time award
Cheese or Melo?
Kyle had a brilliant observation: Alen asked the G to investigate Melo. He said: "If Melo appears to be a G then Hoori and Osman are Gs too". Even though it was a total :wth: logic (since I had always insisted on Melo being a G), I think Alen said that because he was sure that Melo would be proven to be a gangster. I personally feel more comfortable to vote Melo out first.
Kyle had a brilliant observation: Alen asked the G to investigate Melo. He said: "If Melo appears to be a G then Hoori and Osman are Gs too". Even though it was a total :wth: logic (since I had always insisted on Melo being a G), I think Alen said that because he was sure that Melo would be proven to be a gangster. I personally feel more comfortable to vote Melo out first.
Been busy, plus the game seemed set so havent been in a hurry to check things. I will jail the BG if he says who he is in THIS thread right now, the GANGSTERS know who you are, there is no point hiding it. I dont think you protected the detective or someone else they were trying to whack last night, but yourself, dont see a reason you would have. So say it RIGHT NOW. Because the deadline for jailing is 19.00, if you dont, I will jail Hoori instead.
When you out yourself in this thread, the real detective should contact you, since you cant be recruited (though IMO I dont think they recruited first night...and last night Alen the recruiter died), so you can protect the said detective. I prefer not jailing the real detective because it would inform the Gs who he or she is, will only do so tommorrow if they try to whack said detective tonight (and fail when you protect him/her, so very vital you out yourself in this thread right now).
And I gotta love Cheese
(Alen gave him tips of angles to try me thinks lol) Keep him on for tonight because his petty attempts tell us more then the cowardly Melo approach lol. Vote Melo.
When you out yourself in this thread, the real detective should contact you, since you cant be recruited (though IMO I dont think they recruited first night...and last night Alen the recruiter died), so you can protect the said detective. I prefer not jailing the real detective because it would inform the Gs who he or she is, will only do so tommorrow if they try to whack said detective tonight (and fail when you protect him/her, so very vital you out yourself in this thread right now).
And I gotta love Cheese
(Alen gave him tips of angles to try me thinks lol) Keep him on for tonight because his petty attempts tell us more then the cowardly Melo approach lol. Vote Melo. And oh, also, when you out yourself in this thread BG, you can work as a mouthpiece for the detective. We need to know who he/she have been investigating, I hardly think they have been Gs because you either would find a way to tell us here before things became clear, or now they are so clear you shouldnt bother with investigating the original Gs (possible recruit is another thing, thats another thing, need to know when some cvilian was investigated, to sense timing of recruiting or not etc).
The BG role must not revealed by the narrator, that goes without saying. Question is whether or not she should reveal the identity of the Gs' whacking target. My interpretation of the rules is that she shouldn't even though we have never conformed to that rule.
Osman, can the BG protect the D even while being jailed or not?
Osman, can the BG protect the D even while being jailed or not?
And this is what I also said last night, that if the BG protected him/herself last night, he/she should reveal his/her role to the public because the Gs now know about it. The D can then contact the BG and they will work together. But he/she should keep it to him/herself if some other member was protected.
All whacking targets allways get revealed, wether it is the BG himself or someone who was protected is another matter, for us players to figure out, BG's role never gets officially confirmed (only when he is succesfully whacked or lynched). We can discuss that after the game more. But right now, BG was obviously the one who was targeted for whack, and he/she needs to say so openly in this thread.
The D can investigate while in jail, so dont see why the BG couldnt protect either, its related to the straight forward narrative, thats how this game was started to begin with (basic premise, even if we in this forum make jokish versions, the basic should be ze same), story/narrative. And in this context it would be as the detective comes out of jail and checks his case files and finds the proper target of his investigation is conclusive now. Same with BG, comes out of jail at deadline, and hurries to protect targeted victim etc. Thats how I recall it from previous games.
The D can investigate while in jail, so dont see why the BG couldnt protect either, its related to the straight forward narrative, thats how this game was started to begin with (basic premise, even if we in this forum make jokish versions, the basic should be ze same), story/narrative. And in this context it would be as the detective comes out of jail and checks his case files and finds the proper target of his investigation is conclusive now. Same with BG, comes out of jail at deadline, and hurries to protect targeted victim etc. Thats how I recall it from previous games.
The D has investigated twice so far in the game, one of which occurred today after Alen's death. I think the other investigation target must be a perfect choice for the Gs to recruit: the crooked cop has already told the Gs who the D has investigated. They know that the investigated member is now a sure C to the D so they might go for recruiting him/her. The D must take this into consideration.
Osman, the jailed ones can't do what their roles allow them to. The BG can't protect anyone while being jailed. I took a look at the rules again and I'm now sure about that. The BG can't send his protecting request to the narrator. The Gs can whack ANYONE except for the BG who's in jail. I'm sure about that. When the BG comes out of the jail he can send his protecting request to the narrator but the Gs have already whacked someone by the time.