The greatest defender the world has ever seen(new discussion) (1 Viewer)

Who is he?

  • Nesta

  • Kohler

  • Sammer

  • Cannavaro

  • Moore

  • Thuram

  • Hierro (mark,you on drugs?)

  • Scirea

  • Gentile

  • Baresi

  • Beckenbauer

  • Passarella

  • Lizarazu

  • Desailly

  • Maldini

  • Other


Results are only viewable after voting.

JuveAdam

Moggi santo..subito
Sep 12, 2006
1,072
#62
I don't think the problem is watching the old stars or not. To me it seems you would rather glorify Gentile than Nesta solely because he played in a time of football that you enjoy more.

Nesta and Cannavaro ARE the best defenders ever. And if you can't accept that there is something desperately lacking in your way of reading the game.
Gaetano Scirea is one of the only five players in European football history –join to Antonio Cabrini, Sergio Brio, Stefano Tacconi and Danny Blind- to have won all national and international trophies for football clubs recognized by UEFA and FIFA . He played for the Italian national team for more than a decade during which he was almost irreplaceable as the leading defender, and became World Champion with the 1982 FIFA World Cup winning team.
Scirea was a graceful defender of great skill and tactical ability. In contrast to the ruthless tactics often employed by other defenders, Scirea was renowned for his class, fair play and sportsmanship. He was never sent off or suspended during his entire career, which is probably a football record for a defender of international level, and this says a lot about his temperament and the level of his skill.During the 80's Juve was full of stars. Although there were players such as Bettega, Zoff, Tardelli, Platini, Brady, Boniek, Gentile and Furino, just to mention a few of them, there was one above of everyone else. Gaetano Scirea. The club has done what is right and proper by dedicating to Scirea the end where their most fervent supporters gather. He was a clean fighter, capable of transmitting confidence and strength at the same time. On the evening of the Heysel Stadium tragedy in Brussels in May 1985, it was Scirea who spoke on the microphone to try to calm the thousands of people traumatised by what was happening.

In the 1990 World Cup, Italy also conceeded 2 goals, one against Argentina, one from Englands David Platt. Does this mean that in Alexander's reasoning that Zenga-Baresi-Bergomi-Ferri-Maldini is as good as Buffon-Canna-Nesta-Zambro-Grosso?

This blatant disregard for the history of our game is actually frightening. For someone who has never even watched 82 WC highlights to say Canna & Nesta are the worlds best ever defenders is crazy. Yes they are the best of the last ten years, & alongside Maldini & Baresi probably the last 20. The absolute class of Scirea is the yardstick by which ALL Italian defenders are judged. He is without doubt the greatest ever, our Curva is not named in his honour lightly. Might I suggest Alexander looks at the list of legends who've worn our shirt, then thinks that above all these, the curva is named for our Scirea. This alone tells you all you need to know.
 

Bozi

The Bozman
Administrator
Oct 18, 2005
22,740
#63
well said adam and puts over the point i have been trying to convey. class post and post of the month cadidate for me
 
OP
Ascension

Ascension

Senior Member
Sep 16, 2005
1,882
  • Thread Starter
  • Thread Starter #64
    Perfect post. + Rep

    OK, I'm on board. Scirea, Gentile, Cannavaro, Nesta and Desailly are all on the same level of performance.

    I would say though that it would be equally crazy to disregard the present stars of the game which is Nesta and Cannavaro. They are by no means inferior to any of the players you mentioned from the past.

    But, good post, Adam. I'm looking forward to somehow watching Scirea play.

    Then if I find him to be better than the five defenders I mentioned above I will personally get myself an avatar of him here on this forum. :toast:
     

    Red

    -------
    Moderator
    Nov 26, 2006
    47,024
    #67
    Is Der Kaiser being disregarded in terms of the greatest defender ever? Cos he wisnae a bad player ken?
     

    Bozi

    The Bozman
    Administrator
    Oct 18, 2005
    22,740
    #68
    Is Der Kaiser being disregarded in terms of the greatest defender ever? Cos he wisnae a bad player ken?

    that was initally me, at the beginning of this debate

    for me the list is something like this

    1.Gaetano Scirea
    2.Franz Beckenbauer
    3.Franco Baresi
    4.Daniel Passarella
    5.Paolo Maldini
    6.Claudio Gentile


    but i could put many others in there,Alan Hansen,Bobby Moore,Bixente Lizarazu,Marecel Desailly.teh list is endless and i will form a poll soon


    what you think?plese discuss (copyright Abugadanzieri)
    just my 2 cents
     

    Marc

    Softcore Juventino
    Jul 14, 2006
    21,649
    #74
    I'm gonna have to be honest with you. What quality does your life actually hold? I mean, there's nothing even remotely witty or funny about his comeback...? :confused:
    I don´t owe you any explanations. You probably wouldn´t understand a thing.
     

    Bjerknes

    "Top Economist"
    Mar 16, 2004
    111,531
    #75
    I think Materazzi is the best dinosaur to have ever existed, because I was never around to see the actual dinosaurs roam the earth.
     

    Bozi

    The Bozman
    Administrator
    Oct 18, 2005
    22,740
    #76
    okso i will create teh poll later today so far teh candidates are,

    Nesta
    Kohler
    Sammer
    Cannavaro
    Moore
    Thuram
    Hierro (mark,you on drugs?)
    Scirea
    Gentile
    Baresi
    Beckenbauer
    Passarella
    Thuram
    Lizarazu
    Desailly(though he played most of his football as DM)
    Maldini

    anyother you would like to see?
     

    Bozi

    The Bozman
    Administrator
    Oct 18, 2005
    22,740
    #78
    oh aye maldini f course, someone mentoned him, good defender but not an all time great in my eyes but this one is for burke
     

    Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 1)