The greatest defender the world has ever seen(new discussion) (1 Viewer)

[Azzurri7]

I wonder how many of you have really followed Scirea's career.

 

Buy on AliExpress.com

[Lawnchair Bes]

why you bitchin, more people voted for him than cannavaro, get over it

 

[ßöмßäяðîëя]

I voted:

Liza
Der Kaiser
Gentile
Scirea
Maldini

 

[Snoop]

De cock should be in the list

 

[Bozi]

i put liza in there for ya burke, but cant understand why mark83 asked for hierro

as for de cock, well he is a legend in his own right anyway

 

[Lawnchair Bes]

he was great at scoring penalties

 

[Azzurri7]

why you bitchin, more people voted for him than cannavaro, get over it

First...I'm not bitching, It's a simple question. isn't ?

Second, what about Cannavaro? It's not like Del Piero is on the list and I want him to win.

 

[Bozi]

he was great at scoring penalties

de cock?aye he really comes alive when he reaches the box

 

[Snoop]

 

[Il Re]

someone add del piero to the poll and watch how he wins it

 

[Jem83]

Gentile

 

[Red]

I wonder how many of you have really followed Scirea's career.

I didn't vote for him because I haven't seen enough footage of him, same goes for Gentile. I was picking between Cannavaro, Maldini, Baresi and Beckenbauer because they are the only top players I have seen enough of to really judge at all.

I went for Baresi because I am just old enough to have seen a reasonable amount of him and in terms of an out and out defender I think he is the best I has seen.

 

[Joaco]

I voted for 5, but, IMO, Scirea is the best.

Note: for those who saw him play, Ruggeri should be added to the list. He was so much better than Hierro

 

[Bozi]

someone add del piero to the poll and watch how he wins it

lol done....maybe i should give him a head start too

 

[denco]

I am just mystified as to why Lizarazu is anywhere near that list, he is far from been the best left back , he is in my view as a left back inferior to kaltz, roberto carlos, kenny sansom, maldini(best ever), and Cabrini to name guys top of my head and i do not see how putting Thuram there should bring laughter. The Thuram that played for Parma is one of the best that has graced serieA.
He should not be judged by what he is now and his last seasons at Juve as that will be like judging Hierro in his last seasons and Mattheus when he was 35 and older. If Lizarazu is there so should be Blanc, Tresor, Carlos Alberto, well too many defenders ahould be there but its evident that defenders are not players that are well known in this forum as i can throw in names like steilike, macfarland, butcher, adams, charles etc. For me personally my best defender will always be Baresi, with Scirea and Beckenbuaer being right up there

 

[Marc]

I agree. Thuram is an asshole, but he is probably the best defender France ever had.

 

[Red]

I am just mystified as to why Lizarazu is anywhere near that list, he is far from been the best left back , he is in my view as a left back inferior to kaltz, roberto carlos, kenny sansom, maldini(best ever), and Cabrini to name guys top of my head and i do not see how putting Thuram there should bring laughter. The Thuram that played for Parma is one of the best that has graced serieA.
He should not be judged by what he is now and his last seasons at Juve as that will be like judging Hierro in his last seasons and Mattheus when he was 35 and older. If Lizarazu is there so should be Blanc, Tresor, Carlos Alberto, well too many defenders ahould be there but its evident that defenders are not players that are well known in this forum as i can throw in names like steilike, macfarland, butcher, adams, charles etc. For me personally my best defender will always be Baresi, with Scirea and Beckenbuaer being right up there

 

[Alex66]

What about Mattheus? He isnt the world best, but when Nesta and Hierro are there, he should be there too

Beside Mattheus won 1 ballon dOr
And Blanc should be there too

 

[Bozi]

i agree denco but i asked for suggestions on names and burkemeister desperately wanted bixente in there, do i think he is ne of eth top defenders ever?hell no.

however i think he is a much greater player than carlos ever was, why carlos was never moved to LM is a mystery to me as he is a rubbish defender, terrible positioning sense and far too cavalier in attack. sure he has great pace, a tremedously powerful shot and great energy but i wouldnt ahve wanted him anywhere near a juve team, especially with luca zambrotta already in our team.

its a matter of opinion, i asked and these are the names i was given

 

[.zero]

i just get the strangest feeling that nesta/canna/maldini are the only actual contenders on this forum. hmmm..... :rolleyes2

...bastards

forza marcel!
forza liza!