'The Broken City' (11 Viewers)
- Thread starter Ford Prefect
- Start date
OP
Kate moved to turin after years of searching for somewhere to call home. She had tried the UK, USA and Canada, but something was always missing. She knew if she followed her heart and the team she loved she would find her home. She first met the Don in a cafe in the city centre, they both loved literature and the don needed a translator to deal with the french clients of the family. Kate quickly rose through the ranks of the family, proving to be a ruthless killer, and became a made woman. Fast forward to today, and Kate site alone in a prison cell, she can hear the mob taunting her from outside, how had it come to this? The mob kicked down the door of the jail and forced the jailer to open her cell. Kate was forced outside, the mob tied her to a horse and she was dragged through the old cobbled streets. Kate was a Gangster.
Third World Wonder always dreamed of sunnier days living in Turin. He too had followed his heart to this 'broken city'. He grew up in the Caribbean, and he missed the warm summers breaze. It would turn out to be the cause of his death. He had been upsetting people all day, arguing with the townspeople in their pursuit of kate. Alen was talking in a local tavern sarcasticaly about how he in fact wanted Kate killed, only to overheard by the don himself. This for him was the final insult, as a child he had always dreamed of being a black child living in the caribbean and Third World Wonder was a constant reminder of what he couldn't be and now he wanted to kill his translator? Two hitmen were sent out with baseball bats, he was beaten and burried alive in alps. Third World Wonder was a Civillian.
I'm struggling to find the logic in whacking TWW. The only possible explanation is that they thought he's the BG instructed by me to act suspicious.
They simply had to kill the BG today because every other outcome is a civilian win.
Guys (gangsters) calculate what's going to happen. It's a civilian win no matter how you twist it. Even if I investigate Civilians we will vote No Lynch until the two remaining Gs are the only ones left for investigation. Tomorrow I'll be jailed, the BG will be protected, while the day later I will be protected by the BG so I have 3 more investigations at least.
It's a lost game for you.
They simply had to kill the BG today because every other outcome is a civilian win.
Guys (gangsters) calculate what's going to happen. It's a civilian win no matter how you twist it. Even if I investigate Civilians we will vote No Lynch until the two remaining Gs are the only ones left for investigation. Tomorrow I'll be jailed, the BG will be protected, while the day later I will be protected by the BG so I have 3 more investigations at least.
It's a lost game for you.
Ok, remaining options:
Day 1 (tomorrow)
- There are 8 players left. 2 Gs and 6cs. I know 3 confirmed civilians (me, the Bg and the jailer).
- That leaves 5 players whose roles I don't know. 2 are Gs and 3 are Cs.
- I investigate a C
- Now I know exactly which 4 of the remaining 8 players are Cs.
- We vote No Lynch
- The Gs can't kill me or the BG (I am jailed and the bg protects himself)
- The Gs whack a C (lets say they whack the confirmed C)
Day 2
- There are 7 players left. 2 Gs and 5cs. I know 3 confirmed civilians (me, the Bg and the jailer).
- That leaves 4 players whose roles I don't know. 2 are Gs and 2 are Cs.
- I investigate a C
- Now I know exactly which 4 of the remaining 7 players are Cs. I only don't know who are the Gs and the last civilian
- We vote No Lynch
- The Gs can't kill me since I am protected
- The Gs whack a C (in best case for them, the BG)
Day 3
- There are 6players left. 2 Gs and 4cs. I know 3 confirmed civilians (me, the investigated C and the jailer).
- That leaves 3 players whose roles I don't know. 2 are Gs and 1 is a C.
- I investigate a C
- Now I know all the Cs and I know who are the last Gs
- We vote the Gs.
And that's only in case if they don't whack the jailer and give me a new civilian in the new jailer or if they whack the confirmed civilian tomorrow. The above is only in the best scenario for the Gs and they still lose.
Will you play the game, Gs?
Day 1 (tomorrow)
- There are 8 players left. 2 Gs and 6cs. I know 3 confirmed civilians (me, the Bg and the jailer).
- That leaves 5 players whose roles I don't know. 2 are Gs and 3 are Cs.
- I investigate a C
- Now I know exactly which 4 of the remaining 8 players are Cs.
- We vote No Lynch
- The Gs can't kill me or the BG (I am jailed and the bg protects himself)
- The Gs whack a C (lets say they whack the confirmed C)
Day 2
- There are 7 players left. 2 Gs and 5cs. I know 3 confirmed civilians (me, the Bg and the jailer).
- That leaves 4 players whose roles I don't know. 2 are Gs and 2 are Cs.
- I investigate a C
- Now I know exactly which 4 of the remaining 7 players are Cs. I only don't know who are the Gs and the last civilian
- We vote No Lynch
- The Gs can't kill me since I am protected
- The Gs whack a C (in best case for them, the BG)
Day 3
- There are 6players left. 2 Gs and 4cs. I know 3 confirmed civilians (me, the investigated C and the jailer).
- That leaves 3 players whose roles I don't know. 2 are Gs and 1 is a C.
- I investigate a C
- Now I know all the Cs and I know who are the last Gs
- We vote the Gs.
And that's only in case if they don't whack the jailer and give me a new civilian in the new jailer or if they whack the confirmed civilian tomorrow. The above is only in the best scenario for the Gs and they still lose.
Will you play the game, Gs?
OP
Hello, anyone with half a brain left? 
This is a 100% civilian win even in theory. Will we simply waste time to end the game or do we end it now?
Jasper?
This is a 100% civilian win even in theory. Will we simply waste time to end the game or do we end it now?
Jasper?
But why would anyone object? Just think about all the possible scenarios and you'll see that this is a C win.
I know the BG - Sabet and I know the jailer - Gabriel. There is not a single way the gangsters to win this game. Not even in theory (well, except if Sab and Gabe really die and forget to protect me/put me in jail).
Lets just end it and give a round of applause for the two Gs who survived (I don't know who you are, so well played to the remaining two Gs) and to the civilians who survived as well as those who were whacked but played well.
I know the BG - Sabet and I know the jailer - Gabriel. There is not a single way the gangsters to win this game. Not even in theory (well, except if Sab and Gabe really die and forget to protect me/put me in jail).
Lets just end it and give a round of applause for the two Gs who survived (I don't know who you are, so well played to the remaining two Gs) and to the civilians who survived as well as those who were whacked but played well.