'The Broken City' (17 Viewers)

[Ford Prefect]

But why would anyone object? Just think about all the possible scenarios and you'll see that this is a C win.

I know the BG - Sabet and I know the jailer - Gabriel. There is not a single way the gangsters to win this game. Not even in theory (well, except if Sab and Gabe really die and forget to protect me/put me in jail).

Lets just end it and give a round of applause for the two Gs who survived (I don't know who you are, so well played to the remaining two Gs) and to the civilians who survived as well as those who were whacked but played well.

Because its a lot writing i cant be arsed to do until tomorrow

 

Buy on AliExpress.com

[Alen]

Oh, that's cool then

Except the minor mistakes that followed the game, and which were present no matter who was the narrator, you did a monster job narrating this game.

Everyone, +rep Jasper.

 

[king Ale]

Ok, remaining options:

Day 1 (tomorrow)
- There are 8 players left. 2 Gs and 6cs. I know 3 confirmed civilians (me, the Bg and the jailer).
- That leaves 5 players whose roles I don't know. 2 are Gs and 3 are Cs.
- I investigate a C
- Now I know exactly which 4 of the remaining 8 players are Cs.
- We vote No Lynch
- The Gs can't kill me or the BG (I am jailed and the bg protects himself)
- The Gs whack a C (lets say they whack the confirmed C)

Day 2
- There are 7 players left. 2 Gs and 5cs. I know 3 confirmed civilians (me, the Bg and the jailer).
- That leaves 4 players whose roles I don't know. 2 are Gs and 2 are Cs.
- I investigate a C
- Now I know exactly which 4 of the remaining 7 players are Cs. I only don't know who are the Gs and the last civilian
- We vote No Lynch
- The Gs can't kill me since I am protected
- The Gs whack a C (in best case for them, the BG)

Day 3
- There are 6players left. 2 Gs and 4cs. I know 3 confirmed civilians (me, the investigated C and the jailer).
- That leaves 3 players whose roles I don't know. 2 are Gs and 1 is a C.
- I investigate a C
- Now I know all the Cs and I know who are the last Gs
- We vote the Gs.

And that's only in case if they don't whack the jailer and give me a new civilian in the new jailer or if they whack the confirmed civilian tomorrow. The above is only in the best scenario for the Gs and they still lose.

Will you play the game, Gs?

You are right, it's over

 

[Bezzy]

so we quit?

 

[Alen]

I was gonna investigate cheese or janna tomorrow. They were the only 2 sure civilians in my mind and at least one of them had to be a G.

Kyle could be too but he was too inactive and I didn't even consider him.

Nate, Alc could be anything

 

[Alen]

so we quit?

Yup

You are right, it's over

Their last chance to stay in the game was to whack Sabet tonight. If they did then this game was still gonna be wide open. By whacking TWW they made sure that the game is over.

 

[Ford Prefect]

All the remaining players will get a story tomorrow and the roles will be revealed, please don't talk about it until then, dead players can post

 

[Alen]

You're ruining the fun Jasper

Come on, no need for stories now. You can still write them tomorrow and we will still enjoy them, but no need to hide our roles now. It's over.

 

[Klin]

We won.

 

[Fake Melo]

Everyone -REP Hoori for killing me.

 

[Klin]

I bet Nate and ALC were the remaining Gs.

 

[Alen]

TWW won another game. Now it's 4 wins and only 1 defeat for him.

What a player, what a player

But seriously, by getting whacked he singlehandedly won the game for his team. I beat he tricked the Gs into whacking him because he knew that his whacking will bring the win to his team.

What a player

 

[Kate]

It's a big shame that people don't post enough. I know I was relatively silent at first as well, but that's because I know that the moment you open your mouth you're often killed off

 

[ALC]

TWW won another game. Now it's 4 wins and only 1 defeat for him.

What a player, what a player

He's dead so it doesn't really mean anything.

 

[Klin]

It's a big shame that people don't post enough. I know I was relatively silent at first as well, but that's because I know that the moment you open your mouth you're often killed off

Tell me about it. My mouth is what got me killed.

I found being a Civilian was more difficult than being a Gangster.

 

[ALC]

This turned out to be a pretty whack game though. Shame because I feel like Japer's great narrating went to heck for nothing. The main blame should lay on Fred

 

[Klin]

This turned out to be a pretty whack game though. Shame because I feel like Japer's great narrating went to heck for nothing. The main blame should lay on Fred

So, were you the G or not?

 

[Alen]

There is this mistake the normal civilians make. They want everyone to know that they are civilians and they do nothing else but trying to prove their role. That usually gets them whacked.

But we all made the same mistakes in the first 2-3 games. With time one learns what to do and what not to do.

 

[ALC]

So, were you the G or not?

I'm a citizen brah

Yes I was

 

[Klin]

There is this mistake the civilians make. They want everyone to know that they are civilians and they do nothing else but trying to prove their role. That usually gets them whacked.

But we all made the same mistakes in the first 2-3 games. With time one learns what to do and what not to do.

Was this really the first game the Detective played a really big part in?