Techno, Trance & House - Reborn (36 Viewers)

Jun 26, 2007
2,706
Oh dont get me wrong. I respect certain DJs like for instance Slipknot has some awesome turntable skills.
Shows how biased you are. That guy does EXACTLY what you've been bashing here - making weird sounds. But somehow because he plays in a band in the genre you like, he suddenly becomes "skilled".

It definitely seems to rock the floor, people are bouncing and having fun.
But its lacking depth and any real dynamics or emotional content IMO. Works well for a crowd of drunk / coked up people ... Guess its kind of a sign of the times.
The funny thing is that you can level rock music (which you obviously consider superior to electronical music) in just the same way. Which brilliant spectrum of emotions does a band like RATM enlighten upon the listener? You just have to face the fact that rock is very similar to any type of electronical music. They're both very one-dimensional genres, in which the way it sounds (the shape) is more important than what is actually played, the melodies/harmonies (the content). Ever tried playing a RATM riff on piano? If not I suggest you do, then you may realize how stupid it sounds if you look at it from a musical viewpoint.

I'm not trying to bash either rock or electronical music, I can enjoy both and listen to both often. I just find it really, really annoying that almost all rock fans think their genre is superior to electronical music, when in reality they are just about equal in musical quality.


Van Halen is definitely an underrated guitarist. Compare him to Kurt Cobain or even today's John Frusciante. Perhaps not in America seeing that I wouldn't know as much. However nationwide I swear you would be lucky to have half out of 10 men knowing who he is. Try comparing a solo of Stairway to Heaven and Van Halen's Eruption and you'll know what i'm talking about.
I can give you dozens of names of guitar players who are way more underrated by the main public than Van Halen, but you probably wouldn't know them. :shifty: And comparing him to Kurt Cobain is just pointless, since he's a singer in the first place. He didn't become famous by just being a great guitar player like Van Halen. Plus the fact that the shred type of music Van Halen makes just isn't accessible to the main crowd. Almost all big Van Halen fans are guitar players (I bet you are one too) who judge his music from a mere technical viewpoint.


RATM was not close to be amongst the biggest rockbands during their active period. And again I need to emphasize on the word nationwide. Not just talking about America or perhaps the UK. Those days people listen to Incubus, Nirvana, Creed, Oasis, Smashing Pumpkins just to name a few. The least RATM should have stood would be somewhere with these bands unfortunately what we get is nobody knew who the hell was Tom Morello.

Tom Morello made famous his trademark guitar riffs and a highly unusual solo that sounds more like a turntable than a guitar by making use of the toggle switch and rubbing his hand along the strings parallel to the neck of the guitar.
You get to do it in Guitar Hero 3.
Oh really? I just call it "wanking with a tremelo". He wrote pretty good riffs, but his solos are freaking terrible. And yet again very ironical that you like THIS GUY's nonmelodical sounds, which again come down to the same thing as the sounds in a lot of electronical music acts.

20 years before RATM those messages? For your information punk rock were brought into main stream by Greenday. So 20 years before RATM i swear i have no idea what the fuck is punk rock. And what i know is Blink 182 cant stop singing about fucking a dog and Simple Plan are just some kids who cant stop whining about their women.
The phrase I put in bold all sums it up. This is just embarrassing really. Do some wikipedia research or something.

To sum it all up, you're just biased. And instead of acknowleding it, I expect you to come up with more biased arguments.
 

soulslider

Rregula sound
May 16, 2006
3,776
If there's someone i least hate that would have to be Tiesto so lets use his music as an example. Trance...
It definitely seems to rock the floor, people are bouncing and having fun.

don't know why but i had the feeling that you would you use him as an example of a dj you don't hate that much.

I on the other hand hate that guy and don't understand how people can listen to him, but then again that's just me.

as for trance i would say that that is genre of electronic music i don't appreciate at all.
 

IlDivinCodino

f**king hot prospect
Mar 5, 2006
1,191
Shows how biased you are. That guy does EXACTLY what you've been bashing here - making weird sounds. But somehow because he plays in a band in the genre you like, he suddenly becomes "skilled".



The funny thing is that you can level rock music (which you obviously consider superior to electronical music) in just the same way. Which brilliant spectrum of emotions does a band like RATM enlighten upon the listener? You just have to face the fact that rock is very similar to any type of electronical music. They're both very one-dimensional genres, in which the way it sounds (the shape) is more important than what is actually played, the melodies/harmonies (the content). Ever tried playing a RATM riff on piano? If not I suggest you do, then you may realize how stupid it sounds if you look at it from a musical viewpoint.

I'm not trying to bash either rock or electronical music, I can enjoy both and listen to both often. I just find it really, really annoying that almost all rock fans think their genre is superior to electronical music, when in reality they are just about equal in musical quality.




I can give you dozens of names of guitar players who are way more underrated by the main public than Van Halen, but you probably wouldn't know them. :shifty: And comparing him to Kurt Cobain is just pointless, since he's a singer in the first place. He didn't become famous by just being a great guitar player like Van Halen. Plus the fact that the shred type of music Van Halen makes just isn't accessible to the main crowd. Almost all big Van Halen fans are guitar players (I bet you are one too) who judge his music from a mere technical viewpoint.




Oh really? I just call it "wanking with a tremelo". He wrote pretty good riffs, but his solos are freaking terrible. And yet again very ironical that you like THIS GUY's nonmelodical sounds, which again come down to the same thing as the sounds in a lot of electronical music acts.



The phrase I put in bold all sums it up. This is just embarrassing really. Do some wikipedia research or something.

To sum it all up, you're just biased. And instead of acknowleding it, I expect you to come up with more biased arguments.
Pretty neat argument and you're right I AM bias. For one, I know many more underrated guitarist though however used someone not least famous such as Van Halen just to prove a point. And you are somewhat right about Kurt Cobain but the fact that the solo of Smells Like Teen Spirit is in the top 20 of World's Best Guitar Solo is bullshit. Which explains the reason I used him to compare with Van Halen. You really got me on the fact about Slipknot. I am not saying that electro musicians are less genius musicians but merely that they should make full use of their abilities to accommodate proper instruments and not a full blown mixer set.
I will not play a RATM riff on a piano just for the mere fact its a wholly entire different thing. There are certain wonders that can be made with certain instruments and thats what makes them special. The main reason why there would be an orchestra instead of a single piano to play an entire score.

What i quoted in bold is something i've realised a long time ago. Disappointing really in the sense there are so many incredible underground bands who are known to noone when someone like Ashley Simpson who cant even sing for fucks reaches multi platinum status on her debut album. Too bad i'm not entitled to blame nor ask everyone in the world to learn some music just so they can appreciate music in what i think is the most appropriate kind of way. Perhaps that is also the same reason i'm unable to appreciate electro because i myself is not educated in such a way.

To say Morello's work as terrible is your opinion. And i will not disregard it in a sarcastic way like some people would. I respect that. However I find the "wanking in a tremolo" is a major breakthrough in the sense that somehow a turntable screech finally has a tune to it. So its not really non melodical as it goes with a rhythm. And with the wrong chords, it just doesnt sound right. Unlike a DJ who can screech all they want without worrying about mistakes. Thats just me, i appreciate it. And i will not prove your opinion differently.

Just something I would like for you to know is the true reason behind my love for RATM and many other bands of the past is the fact that they are true to themselves. Which I believe everyone should. Speak out what they truly want and not be afraid about the feedbacks. Likewise to the forums where i would challenge your opinions and I'm glad to have a constructive debate where you could prove me doubtful in many senses. But then again we are just humans and everyone is entitled to their own opinions. Unlike someone like Bon Jovi who would have thousands of girls crying over him, willing to die for him and obviously he fucks around with his own opportunity to become a playboy. Thats what i call a hypocrite when he keeps on singing about his undying love over one female. And i truly disrespect this sort of person.

The fact that i have no idea about punk rock i will not ever be embaressed about it. Afterall i'm educated in these times and have already develop a hatred towards that genre (thanks to Blink and Simple Plan etc) thus am not even willing to take the initiative to wiki about it. Before punk reaches mainstream i admit i have ZERO knowledge about them. And their drum beats are just gay.

Last but not least, i will admit i am bias again. And thanks to your argument i believe i do not have the rights to post in this thread again. This place is for electro lovers and obviously i am not lol. Anyhow, you have lots of my respect after your post and am looking forward to many more interesting stuff you will be writing in the future. Not concerning our clashes of opinion but instead on the things that matters most in this forum. Juventus. Good luck to all of us :)
 

Tom

The DJ
Oct 30, 2001
11,726
Works well for a crowd of drunk / coked up people ... Guess its kind of a sign of the times.
Fucking stereotyping cunt!! Shut the fuck up, talking about a scene and lifestyle choice you know nothing about. Thats really wound me up....

WAS gonna have a serious debate with you until I ready that, you clearly have no clue
 

IlDivinCodino

f**king hot prospect
Mar 5, 2006
1,191
Fucking stereotyping cunt!! Shut the fuck up, talking about a scene and lifestyle choice you know nothing about. Thats really wound me up....

WAS gonna have a serious debate with you until I ready that, you clearly have no clue
No dont worry about it. I mean no harm. I'm clueless like you said. Read my previous post and you'll know I have no business in this thread
 

JCK

Biased
JCK
May 11, 2004
125,366
Of course it is, and it is much better live. I've seen them twice and they performed it on both occasions and it was amazing both times.
 

Tom

The DJ
Oct 30, 2001
11,726
No dont worry about it. I mean no harm. I'm clueless like you said. Read my previous post and you'll know I have no business in this thread
I've read it, and your right. Trust me, dj's DO worry about mistakes, and screetching around as you put it is more for hip hop dj's anyway, here its more about creating a 2 3 or 4 hour masterpiece, seamlessly intermingled from 20, 30 tracks, creating such a wonderful atmosphere and sound that takes you away to a better place. Possibly by using up to 4 turntables but there's no talent there obviously! :bum:
 

Cuti

The Real MC
Jul 30, 2006
13,517
Who cares if you have to spend 1 week trying to find the perfect beat and mix, its just on a computer.

Plus Tiesto is probably one of the most commercial deejays around, in fact his 'best' songs are the ones that aren't really launched, such as Your loving Arms, which is a relaxed song.

Imo its just as if not harder for a dj to create a great 1 or 2 hour set than for a band to create a song.
 

Enron

Tickle Me
Moderator
Oct 11, 2005
75,658
No dont worry about it. I mean no harm. I'm clueless like you said. Read my previous post and you'll know I have no business in this thread
I dont think you really have any business discussing music in general. If Rage Against The Machine, Green Day, Blink 182, and Simple Plan are the examples you've chosen to make your points then we all have assume you don't know much about music in general.

Let's be honest here, you were trolling for a fight. And by the way Slipknot is total dog shack.
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 36)