V, i know you want to present your case as good as you can... but seriously... you are practically alone on this one. And is almost disrespectful and borderline trolling.
You seem to ignore he was until yesterday, a Mr. no one of 22 years old who was thrown against one of the best teams in the world in a CL semi. Thats a recipe for disaster in 80% of the cases, but he manned up and delivered a solid performance considering his curriculum.
You are being wayy to harsh and selective, because his presence was indeed felt and he was brimming with confidence from minute 1..even having one of the first shots.
- - - Updated - - -
Btw, what was your previous nickname? I recognize your avatar but not your V name.