Not sure where Bayern came from, but Davids would be better at Bayern just like Davids would be better at any team right now. That's because Vidal isn't peak Vidal right now and lost (or hasn't yet regained) his attacking prowess.
Well, when we specifically talk about the way they use them. Vidal should be able to play aggressive and cover alot of ground. Make attacking runs etc
At bayern he's used as the defensive midfielder who mostly has to cover behind those 5 players, and needs to catch up what goes trough that. Wich is sort off what a Davids or did, or a Marchisio(in a different way).
However, considering its guardiola, the passing aspect is very important, and davids was much better technique+passing wise. And not remotely the goal treath that Vidal was.
Not sure who'd i prefer in their primes at juve. Tho nostalgia makes me think davids, as he really was that damn good. But for the position at bayern, davids regardless of what form vidal is in. They are wasting him.
Guardiola is excellent at wasting players. Wasted Mascherano as cb, lahm as cdm, vidal as cdm, gotze as pocketanus , luis gustavo as fucking sold him, zlatan ibrahimovic,...
- - - Updated - - -
Vidal at his best scored 15 goals and provided 7 assists per season on top of being the best ball-winner in the world. That's two WC midfielders in one.
As great as Davids was, pre-knee-op Vidal was simply better.
Hmm, might now want to say that when anyone from Holland is around, because they'll get very mad
