Radja Nainggolan - CM - Cagliari/Roma (39 Viewers)

Asamoah or Nainggolan?

  • Asamoah

  • Nainggolan


Results are only viewable after voting.
Status
Not open for further replies.

Suns

Release clause?
May 22, 2009
22,090
Suns, you must agree that this makes some sense. :agree:
No I don't actually. It's the stars that bring the interest and money that Juventus needs and teams like Chievo have no chance even if they reach a better stability. Also, it all goes back to the TV revenue thing which the smaller teams make all the money from since Serie A divide the money in a much more fair way than they do over at Spain for example.

There is nothing to be afraid of. Even when Milan and Inter signed guys like Ronaldo, Sheva and the rest of the stars we still kicked their asses year after year.
 

Buy on AliExpress.com

Lapa

FLY, EAGLES FLY
Sep 29, 2008
20,044
No I don't actually. It's the stars that bring the interest and money that Juventus needs and teams like Chievo have no chance even if they reach a better stability. Also, it all goes back to the TV revenue thing which the smaller teams make all the money from since Serie A divide the money in a much more fair way than they do over at Spain for example.

There is nothing to be afraid of. Even when Milan and Inter signed guys like Ronaldo, Sheva and the rest of the stars we still kicked their asses year after year.
...some sense... :D
 

MikeM

Footballing Hipster celebrating 4th place with Tuz
Sep 21, 2008
12,850
You guys are talking crazy right now. Was Inter complaining when we were in Serie B? They won the league 5 times, they won the CL and they won a friggin treble. Were they crying without us there? They experienced perhaps the greatest period of their history.
 

Pirlo's Beard

Junkie Joe Joyce
Oct 2, 2013
11,411
Exactly.

If the entire league improved and we all got a huge chunk of extra T.V money, sponsorship deals etc then fine

But Inter Milan suddnely coming out of nowhere and fighting tooth & nail with us for the scudetto doesn't help us.

It damages us. Not to mention they would even be in a position to fight with us over potential transfer targets.


Serie A taking a leap up in quality = Good

Us having a major rival whilst the rest of the league is equally as terrible as it is now = Not good. We're not going to get a vastly improved T.V deal if one of the Milanese clubs come back from the dead. That's a pipe dream.
 

MikeM

Footballing Hipster celebrating 4th place with Tuz
Sep 21, 2008
12,850
And the most important thing is making the CL year after year and there are only 3 spots currently. Now people want to fight Inter, Milan, Roma, Napoli, Fiorentina every year for those spots.

Ya ok.
 

Pirlo's Beard

Junkie Joe Joyce
Oct 2, 2013
11,411
Not really. Your proposed 'big picture' is a fantasy

I'm trying really hard to think of a case in history where 1 or 2 teams improving has elevated the league to vastly improved TV deals and sponsorship deals.

I'll tell you exactly who benefits from Milan undergoing a revival....

Milan do. Not us, not the entire league. Milan.
 

MikeM

Footballing Hipster celebrating 4th place with Tuz
Sep 21, 2008
12,850
Man, the big picture is really lost on you guys.
No it's not. Your big picture is basically an absolute best case scenario for us that ignores all the RISKS involved with our rivals strengthening which at the very, very basic level include us missing out on one of the limited CL spots in our league.

Would I love to be the best team in the best league in the world with billions of dollars in revenue? Sure. But I like where we are right now, building slowly and steadily, owning our own stadium, increasing global appeal (with which winning helps btw). We are already experiencing the benefits of dominating our league: For example, Tevez taking a pay cut and Llorente waiting 6 months to join us.

You, and many others, are caught reminiscing about the past incarnations of the Serie A and the footballing world in general. Nowadays, you can get as much TV revenue as you want but if you don't have an Oil Sheik for an owner, you will lose out more often than not when chasing a top player.

Then it becomes a question of what are the other more responsible methods to accrue top players and your answer will be the youth ranks. Establishing a monopoly on our domestic talents whether they are Italian or not can only be seen as a good thing and we are experiencing the benefits right now with Pogba and soon Berardi.

If I can exchange our ability to compete with spending 40/50/60M on one top player for the rights to vacuum up all the top youngsters in the nation like Bayern does, then I will choose that path because it will ultimately lead to an extremely formidable team, capable of CL success and world wide following which will only churn out higher revenue.
 

Hist

Founder of Hism
Jan 18, 2009
11,624
You guys are talking crazy right now. Was Inter complaining when we were in Serie B? They won the league 5 times, they won the CL and they won a friggin treble. Were they crying without us there? They experienced perhaps the greatest period of their history.
Financially speaking, they had a horrible time despite winning more trophies than any previous period. Inter used to make more money finishing 3rd and exiting the CL at the last 16 round than they did winning scudettos or the CL. Calciopoli hit all serie A very hard.
 

Suns

Release clause?
May 22, 2009
22,090
Not really. Your proposed 'big picture' is a fantasy

I'm trying really hard to think of a case in history where 1 or 2 teams improving has elevated the league to vastly improved TV deals and sponsorship deals.

I'll tell you exactly who benefits from Milan undergoing a revival....

Milan do. Not us, not the entire league. Milan.
If you can't see the fall that the Italian league has experienced the last few years then I can't really help you. Football is all about money and money comes only through interest and us being in a watered down league is not good for us.

And both Inter and Milan becoming more competitive is good for us. They are powerhouses and like it or not they are the only two teams besides us that can make a difference. We can only go this far without the Serie A. You see, there is a reason why Agnelli. Marotta and Galliani constantly talk about how important it is for the Italian teams to do well and it has nothing to do with all the love they have for each other.
 

Suns

Release clause?
May 22, 2009
22,090
No, but I agree if most of the league improved then long-term we would benefit

But it's going to take a hell of a lot more than 1 or 2 clubs improving, that's what i'm saying
That is the biggest and most important change that has to happen for this league. The rest of the league can financially only go as far as the big 3 teams lead them.

The easy and simple answer would be if Milan, Inter and Juventus were sold to Russian's and Arabs tomorrow. The league would become prestigious again as soon as the next mercato opens but obviously that will not happen.

There is one thing that the Italian league has going for it and that is that we have 3 elite teams and its very important to keep it that way.
 

Vlad

In Allegri We Trust
May 23, 2011
24,064
Not really. Your proposed 'big picture' is a fantasy

I'm trying really hard to think of a case in history where 1 or 2 teams improving has elevated the league to vastly improved TV deals and sponsorship deals.

I'll tell you exactly who benefits from Milan undergoing a revival....

Milan do. Not us, not the entire league. Milan.
Look at it this way; Milan have large fan base abroad, bigger than Juventus for instance, and if they find themselves on the margins for too long will the viewing figures of Serie A stay around the same level or plummet? Juve, Milan and Inter are the most important clubs in Italy, undeniably, looking from economical perspective or historical, clubs with the most appeal abroad and while I enjoy their sufferings atm I hope they get back on their feet. This situation if prolongs can't benefit Juventus in the long run and I'd rather that teams like Roma and Napoli return to their mediocrity.
 

Nejc

Senior Member
May 13, 2006
2,011
No, but I agree if most of the league improved then long-term we would benefit

But it's going to take a hell of a lot more than 1 or 2 clubs improving, that's what i'm saying
:tup:

Selling to teams like PSG or Manchester City is in my opinion the best for Serie A right now. Everybody is saying that Milan and Inter should pick themselves up, but I don't see any big effect of that on lesser teams. Isn't it better for Cagliari to sell Nainggolan to PSG who overpays without much thought that to haggle with some broke ass team like Milan who can't even afford Radja without squeezing in some bullshit Primavera players?
 

MikeM

Footballing Hipster celebrating 4th place with Tuz
Sep 21, 2008
12,850
Look at it this way; Milan have large fan base abroad, bigger than Juventus for instance, and if they find themselves on the margins for too long will the viewing figures of Serie A stay around the same level or plummet? Juve, Milan and Inter are the most important clubs in Italy, undeniably, looking from economical perspective or historical, clubs with the most appeal abroad and while I enjoy their sufferings atm I hope they get back on their feet. This situation if prolongs can't benefit Juventus in the long run and I'd rather that teams like Roma and Napoli return to their mediocrity.
If they find themselves on the margins for too long and we continue to dominate then those fans from abroad will slowly become our fans. Fans from abroad have no political or territorial affiliation to any team. They usually pick the best teams to cheer for. Then once you have a huge following, your sponsorship deals will increase.

Bayern plays in a shit league. It's not like everyone around the world suddenly woke up and decided to cheer for Bayern. They decided to cheer for the best team in Germany.
 

Vlad

In Allegri We Trust
May 23, 2011
24,064
If they find themselves on the margins for too long and we continue to dominate then those fans from abroad will slowly become our fans. Fans from abroad have no political or territorial affiliation to any team. They usually pick the best teams to cheer for. Then once you have a huge following, your sponsorship deals will increase.

Bayern plays in a shit league. It's not like everyone around the world suddenly woke up and decided to cheer for Bayern. They decided to cheer for the best team in Germany.
Like us for instance. We're foreign fans, but have we jumped ship when Juve were in Serie B? But interest of some decreased I assume in that period, at least for Serie A games. It would need decades for the effect to make a change and in the mean time we would gain absolutely nothing with it.
 

MikeM

Footballing Hipster celebrating 4th place with Tuz
Sep 21, 2008
12,850
Like us for instance. We're foreign fans, but have we jumped ship when Juve were in Serie B? But interest of some decreased I assume in that period, at least for the Serie A.
Few will switch allegiances but we can capture the interest of the younger generation surely.

You have to look at the team as a brand. If we're simply the best brand in Italy, then there's nothing that can hurt us as long as the league doesn't turn into Portugal or France quality. If it stays like this and maybe Inter and Milan take a slight step up back into respectability but not enough to hurt us, that would be ideal.

It's like having a monopoly. It can only be good as long as our league remains relevant which I'm sure it will.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 39)