Paul Pogba (179 Viewers)

How many minutes will he play for jj in 23-24 season?


  • Total voters
    33
  • Poll closed .

dolph

Senior Member
Mar 30, 2006
2,599
For me it's:

De Gea = Courtoius
Shaw < Alonso
Valencia=Moses
Baily < Luiz
Smalling < Apilicueta
Pogba < Matic; Pogba has superior technical abilities but Matic is the better team player
Herrera < Kante
Zlatan < Costa
Martial < Pedro; c'mon, Pedro is class
Mata = Hazard ; both are talented and both are inconsistent
So if you could choose between Zlatan, Pogba, Martial and Matic, Costa, Pedro you would go with the Chelsea trio? You need to put down the crack pipe.
 

Fr3sh

Senior Member
Jul 12, 2011
37,249
So if you could choose between Zlatan, Pogba, Martial and Matic, Costa, Pedro you would go with the Chelsea trio? You need to put down the crack pipe.
lol

Costa is one of the best strikers around, while we are witnessing Zlatan's decline in a very physical league. Matic provides consistency, fluidity and is reliable defensively, while Pogba is a non-factor when he is not in a well oiled midfield like our old one. Martial vs Pedro, Martial would be the wise choice however Pedro's experience and tactical intelligence has been invaluable in almost every side he's been, that would make it very hard to overlook him for an unexperienced, inconsistent youngster.

Conte has the better trio and that trio isn't on it's own, Matic is partnered by Kante and Luiz coming up to provide more presence, Pedro compliments Hazard who was known to be inconsistent and a flat track bully, Hazard-Costa-Pedro is a fearsome trio backed with competent wingbacks.

Chelsea doesn't have just a trio, they've got a team. Man U barely has a trio, they've got a bunch of confused individuals.
 

dolph

Senior Member
Mar 30, 2006
2,599
lol

Costa is one of the best strikers around, while we are witnessing Zlatan's decline in a very physical league. Matic provides consistency, fluidity and is reliable defensively, while Pogba is a non-factor when he is not in a well oiled midfield like our old one. Martial vs Pedro, Martial would be the wise choice however Pedro's experience and tactical intelligence has been invaluable in almost every side he's been, that would make it very hard to overlook him for an unexperienced, inconsistent youngster.

Conte has the better trio and that trio isn't on it's own, Matic is partnered by Kante and Luiz coming up to provide more presence, Pedro compliments Hazard who was known to be inconsistent and a flat track bully, Hazard-Costa-Pedro is a fearsome trio backed with competent wingbacks.

Chelsea doesn't have just a trio, they've got a team. Man U barely has a trio, they've got a bunch of confused individuals.
In general I agree with the team vs individuals comment. I do think that Chelsea has the better team, but you got to be kidding on your assesment of the mentioned players as individuals.
Costa is the biggest asshole in the football world, but a very good CF non the less. Zlatan has been a top 3 CF in the world for the last 10 years, and last year he had the Best season of hes carriere. Hes having some trouble in the last couple of games, but that doesent mean he is declining and as a CF he still far superior to Costa.
Martial was outstanding last year one of the best players in the PL, while Pedro was shit. At the moment Pedro is in better form than Martial but on a individual level there is just no comparison.
I am a big fan of Matic. I think he is an outstanding CM, but comparing him to Pogba is just stupid. Pogba is the best CM in football when on form and hes trouble at the moment doesent change that. Only a butthurt Juve fan would take Matic over Pogba.
The funny thing is that Matic, Pedro and Costa where all absolutely shit last year, when the Chelsea team did not function under Mourinho. Noe all of a siden they are better individual players than Zlatan, Pogba and Martial because they are in a team thats functioning.
 

italiacalcio10

Senior Member
Mar 3, 2014
3,866
So if you could choose between Zlatan, Pogba, Martial and Matic, Costa, Pedro you would go with the Chelsea trio? You need to put down the crack pipe.
It's closer than you think.

Ibra is 34. At this stage of his career, Costa is a much more effective player.
Matic is no slouch, but obviously Pogba is better. That being said, in the role that Mourinho is using him, it isn't that far off.
Pedro>Martial - Martial is extremely unproven. He could become a star, but at this point, Pedro is better.

- - - Updated - - -

For me it's:

De Gea = Courtoius
Shaw < Alonso
Valencia=Moses
Baily < Luiz
Smalling < Apilicueta
Pogba < Matic; Pogba has superior technical abilities but Matic is the better team player
Herrera < Kante
Zlatan < Costa
Martial < Pedro; c'mon, Pedro is class
Mata = Hazard ; both are talented and both are inconsistent
Hazard is significantly better. Hazard I would take, Mata I would not.
 

R.A.B.

Senior Member
Mar 24, 2009
525
Matić is better defensively, Pogba ofensively. Baily is not worse defender than Luiz but someone calls Alonso better than Shaw and Pedro better than Martial ? Lmao :lol: , Shaw had big injury but in his debut season he was in top XI premier league season. Alonso? He was not even in top 3 leftbacks in serie a, maybe not even top 5
 

Tak!

Senior Member
Jun 23, 2011
4,176
I'd buy him, he's entertaining and he's very marketable. :D

Imagine a young BonBon-David Luiz CB partnership :lol:
That's straight on point, he's a joke. Love watching his free kicks hit row z and his defensive skills are on par with Maccarone. He is very marketable, though.

Someone worthy of BonBon's backheel defending, that would be a sight to watch in a charity game. It would however, get more people aware of BonBon's skills and being one of the best CBs in the world since he would have to step in to Luiz brainfarts every game.
 

Fr3sh

Senior Member
Jul 12, 2011
37,249
That's straight on point, he's a joke. Love watching his free kicks hit row z and his defensive skills are on par with Maccarone. He is very marketable, though.

Someone worthy of BonBon's backheel defending, that would be a sight to watch in a charity game. It would however, get more people aware of BonBon's skills and being one of the best CBs in the world since he would have to step in to Luiz brainfarts every game.
Nah not 2015 BonBon, not even 2014 BonBon, I'm talking about 2010-2011 BonBon

But yeah Luiz is a joke of a defender, would rather gamble on Smalling or some other garbage English CB
 

kao_ray

Senior Member
Feb 28, 2014
6,568
Luiz is a joke of a player. Wouldn't take him even as a freebie unless I had a gun to my head.
Luiz is a poor defender but Bailey is simply far worse IMO. Honestly, I would accept only a few players from both clubs and Chelsea has the better ones.

And all that hype about Martial... Is it only from his transfer fee, because I have seen so much poor performances from him in MU I really don't think he is as proven as Pedro and I'm quite surprise many people go with the hype.
 

Kopanja

Senior Member
Jul 30, 2015
5,592
Marial looks to me more far more versatile and with higher ceiling than Pedro, the latter one is proven though, but I don't mind Martial for reasonable price (<= 23-25 mln) in Juve and don't want to see Pedro anywhere near our team.
Luiz and Bailey are equally bad at the moment. But imo in proper set up Baily has a chance to be a decent defender. Luiz is a ticking bomb, only set up that prevents him from occasional brainfarts is the one where he is benched.
 

Kopanja

Senior Member
Jul 30, 2015
5,592
I doubt he is in a such bad shape that Rooney or Lingard is picked before him, whenever I've seen him playing mu this season he is at least trying to create something, not only passing the ball to the Fellaini. By no means, Martial is a world-beater, but Lingard is awful and Rooney is shameful.
 

R.A.B.

Senior Member
Mar 24, 2009
525
Luiz is a poor defender but Bailey is simply far worse IMO.
And all that hype about Martial... Is it only from his transfer fee, because I have seen so much poor performances from him in MU I really don't think he is as proven as Pedro and I'm quite surprise many people go with the hype.
bullshit. Luiz is great passer and going forward but as a defender he is not as good as Bailly.


You`ve seen many poor performance from Martial. Whole world have seen how useless was Pedro last Year. Squad player for Barca, squad player for Chelsea.
 

italiacalcio10

Senior Member
Mar 3, 2014
3,866
I personally always thought Luiz could suit the central position in the back three. He is an awkward player - not good enough defensively for a back two, but not intelligent enough with the ball to play as a CDM. That central role in a back three is meant for him. What Chelsea don't need is Bonucci - that would be redundant, and it is obvious that Luiz was the alternative to Bonucci. I personally don't think Luiz on Chelsea in a back three will struggle much, as long as the other two central defenders do their job. He will never be as good as Bonucci, but he can fill the need in that formation.
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 160)