Good points. On the flip side I think his size would also be of use to us as well since Serie A is a more physical game. It might not be as fast as Spain or EPL but it is more physical IMO. Everyone seems to worry about Criscito's size affecting his defensive play (which I am not really one of those) BUT, if you look at Chiellini and how often his size works to his advantage in times such as 1v1s or crosses I think a partner for him in the middle of equal physique (or close) would be splendid. Especially with the general weakness in defensive capabilities of our outside backs, teams like to try and attack us on the wings rather than try and out muscle Chiellini, Poulsen, Marchisio or Sissoko in the middle. So unless we strengthen our RB area IMO someone of a generally large physique would be more reassurance for our CBs to partner Chiellini in the middle.
I also agree but in our case, we already have this huge on partner on the viking Mellberg and we prefer the National team Legro instead, because he is Italian, a good Christian, loyal, cheap etc and therefore we want to support his chances of representing the Italian NT in Africa! The presence of those means that a 3th Cb would get minimal chances if he cant offer what their proven experience and teamwork may offer right away.
The only reason a less exp player would get some chances, is a very talented young defender who would offer the same if not better performances as they can offer and a far better perspective for the future.
The task for this new defender at this very moment is very demanding, due to our depth and subber standards. We have already made a big investment on Criscito's half and we are likely to take our chances with him first.
I dont see a place for a 3rd CB as Subotic's atm. But if Criscito fails again, then we will buy someone like him!
And i also agree that our fullbacks are a priority, the RB should be fixed asap because we cannot spend one more year with Grygera as a starter and Zebina has lost his last chance this year...